The Collected Works of Ambrose Bierce, Volume 09: Tangential ViewsBierce, Ambrose
General
The Collected Works of Ambrose Bierce, Volume 09: Tangential Views
Bierce, Ambrose
American essays; American literature
It may be that proponents of euthanasia for suffering incurables are
pushing their adventurous feet too far ahead in the march of mind to
expect anything better in the nature of encouragement than a copious
dead-catting and bad-egging from laggard processionists arear.
Sometimes, however, they get decenter treatment than they have the
hardihood to claim: occasionally, through the roar of calumniation is
heard the voice of dull and dignified protestation, even of argument.
For example, _The British Medical Journal_ once pointed out, with
more gravity than grammar, that “the medical profession has always
strongly set its face against a measure that would inevitably pave
the way to the grossest abuses, and which would degrade them to the
position of executioners.”
I don’t know that the medical profession speaks with any special
authority in a matter of this kind. Perhaps it knows a little better
than other trades and professions that cases of hopeless agony are
of frequent occurrence, but as to the expediency of relieving them
by the compassionate _coup de grâce_—of that a physician is no
better judge than anyone else. As to the fear of being “degraded to the
position of executioners,” the position is not degrading. The office of
executioner—even when execution is punishment, not mercy—is, and should
be considered, an almost sacred office. Its popular disrepute harks
back to the bad old days when a majority of the people in countries
now partly civilized were criminal in act or sympathy, living in hate
and terror of the law—the days of Tyburn Tree with its roaring mobs,
cheering the malefactor and pelting the hangman. It was not from fear
of a merely social reprobation that the mediæval headsman wore a mask;
it was from fear of being torn to pieces if ever recognized unguarded
in the public street. A man of to-day, ambitious to prove his descent
from a criminal ancestry, can most easily do so by damning the hangman.
His humble origin is no disgrace to him if he is a good citizen, but it
makes him invincible to the suasion of argument against his fad. One
might as profitably attempt to reform the color of his eyes or dissuade
him from the shape of his nose.
II
“It is a physician’s mission to cure disease and alleviate suffering,”
says Dr. Nehemiah Nickerson. “There is a point beyond which he can not
cure disease; after that it is his duty to alleviate suffering.”
A mission implies a mandate; a mandate an authority superior to that of
the missionary. I do not know from what higher authority a physician
derives his own, nor who has the right to lay down the lines within
which his activity must lie. Within the civil and the moral law he is
a free agent—free to observe or disregard the customs of his trade, as
conscience may determine. He has no mandate, no mission.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account