The complete works of John Gower, volume 1 : $b The French worksGower, John
General
The complete works of John Gower, volume 1 : $b The French works
Gower, John
Poetry
PRINTED EDITIONS.--The _Balades_ have been twice printed. They were
published by the Roxburghe Club in 1818, together with the other
contents of the Trentham MS. except the English poem, with the title
‘Balades and other Poems by John Gower. Printed from the original MS.
in the library of the Marquis of Stafford at Trentham,’ Roxburghe Club,
1818, 4to. The editor was Earl Gower. This edition has a considerable
number of small errors, several of which obscure the sense; only a
small number of copies was printed, and the book can hardly be obtained.
In 1886 an edition of the _Balades_ and of the _Traitié_ was published
in Germany under the name of Dr. Edmund Stengel in the series of
‘Ausgaben und Abhandlungen aus dem Gebiete der romanischen Philologie.’
The title of this book is ‘John Gower’s Minnesang und Ehezuchtbüchlein:
LXXII anglonormannische Balladen ... neu herausgegeben von Edmund
Stengel.’ Marburg, 1886. The preface is signed with the initials D.
H. The editor of this convenient little book was unable to obtain
access to the original MS., apparently because he had been wrongly
informed as to the place where it was to be found, and accordingly
printed the _Balades_ from the Roxburghe edition with such emendations
as his scholarship suggested. He removed a good many obvious errors
of a trifling kind, and in a few cases he was successful in emending
the text by conjecture. Some important corrections, however, still
remained to be made, and in several instances he introduced error
into the text either by incorrectly transcribing the Roxburghe edition
or by unsuccessful attempts at emendation. I do not wish to speak
with disrespect of this edition. The editor laboured under serious
disadvantages in not being able to refer to the original MS. and in not
having always available even a copy of the Roxburghe edition, so that
we cannot be surprised that he should have made mistakes. I have found
his text useful to work upon in collation, and some of his critical
remarks are helpful.
THE PRESENT TEXT.--The text of this edition is based directly on the
MS., which remains still in the library at Trentham Hall and to which
access was kindly allowed me by the Duke of Sutherland. I propose to
describe the MS. fully, since it is of considerable interest, and being
in a private library it is not generally accessible.
The Trentham MS., referred to as T., is a thin volume, containing 41
leaves of parchment, measuring about 6¼ in. x 9¼ in., and made up
apparently as follows: a^4, b^1, c^6, d--f^8 (one leaf cut out), g^1,
h^4, i^2 (no catchwords).
The first four leaves and the last two are blank except for notes of
ownership, &c., so that the text of the book extends only from f. 5 to
f. 39, one leaf being lost between f. 33 and f. 34.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account