The constitution violated : $b An essayButler, Josephine Elizabeth Grey
History
The constitution violated : $b An essay
Butler, Josephine Elizabeth Grey
Constitutional law -- Great Britain; Prostitutes -- Legal status, laws, etc. -- Great Britain
In recent numbers of the _Lancet_ there has been a correspondence on
the desirableness, from the doctor’s point of view, of making it
compulsory on all women of the humbler classes, on pain of fine or
imprisonment, to be attended in childbearing by a male practitioner.
One of the correspondents says there is such a provision in the new
“Medical Bill,” but on looking through that Bill I cannot find such a
provision, unless indeed it be artfully concealed in clause 29. The
_Lancet_, it is well known, is ever the friend of compulsion and
violent centralization, abounding in such expressions as the
following:—“It is to be regretted that a well instructed and humane
government does not exercise a firmer influence over the anarchy, the
greed, the ignorance of local governing bodies. But the energetic use
of the powers given by the Sanitary Acts would enable medical men to
confer benefits on the public, the value of which defies
estimation.”—_Lancet._ These benefits conferred by medical men, be it
observed, are to be purchased at the expense of that power of
self-government, disposition to help the law, and manly independence
which, as we have seen, De Tocqueville, Montalembert, Niebuhr, Guizot,
and a host of thoughtful English writers, have attributed to a great
extent to the freedom of local governing bodies. It might be asked
further, is there no danger of anarchy, of greed, of ignorance among
medical men?
Footnote 90:
_Liverpool Mercury._
Footnote 91:
If we compare the slight penalties inflicted for cruelties practised
on women and children with those imposed for injury of property or the
wounding of a stag, the property of a Duke, we cannot wonder at the
low estimate, in England, of the worth of women.
Footnote 92:
_Commentaries_, p. 142, chap. viii.
Footnote 93:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account