The Cornhill Magazine (Vol. I, No. 3, March 1860)Various
History
The Cornhill Magazine (Vol. I, No. 3, March 1860)
Various
England -- Periodicals; English literature -- Periodicals; Short stories, English -- Periodicals
long knock about amongst his fellows, mistaking motives, misinterpreting
acts, confounding affections, and failing to form a correct estimate of
the persons he meets—until, at last, after much experience and many
errors, he learns to hit the mark without knowing how he does it. The
study of the human mind, as pursued in the Scottish universities, has
such an effect, that in after life it is an object of incessant interest
to all Scotchmen. The average Scotchman will give a shrewder guess than
the average Englishman as to a man’s character, and a better description
of it. He has studied the anatomy of character so minutely that he
delights in portraiture and excels in biography. The proper study of
mankind is man—everybody admits. Whether the best way of prosecuting
that study is in reading through the classics, and piling up algebraic
formulas, I do not know; but, at all events, the Scottish universities
have something to say for themselves, not if they neglect the classics
and the mathematics, but if they simply elevate above these branches
of knowledge a direct acquaintance with the mysteries of human nature,
in thought and in feeling, in expression and in act. Apart from all
comparison between English and Scottish university life, the psychology
and moral philosophy of the North are at least worthy of the highest
praise, as an antidote and recompence for the evil that is felt in the
absence of student life.
Yet another compensation for the defects of the social system will be
found in the professorial method of teaching, when it is conducted with
spirit. The common idea of a professor is, that of a man wearing a gown,
and reading dull lectures every day for an hour to students, some of whom
are taking notes, while the rest are dozing. Professor Blackie, Professor
Aytoun, Professor Ferrier, and the late Sir William Hamilton would give
to any one entering their class-rooms a very different idea of what a
professor ought to be. Sir William Hamilton’s class was perhaps the most
marvellously conducted class in any university. About 150 students were
ranged on seats before the professor, who lectured three days in the
week, and on two days held a sort of open conference with his pupils,
which was conducted in this wise:—Sir William dipped his hand into an
urn and took out a letter of the alphabet—say M. Any student whose
name began with M was then at liberty to stand up and comment on the
professor’s lectures—attack them—illustrate them—report them—say almost
anything, however far-fetched, which had any relation to them. A couple
of Macs get up at once. The first merely raises a laugh by topping one
of his William’s philosophical anecdotes with another which he fancies
to be still better. The second gets up, and has a regular tussle with
his master about the action of the mind in sleep, and in a state of
semi-consciousness. It is all over in five minutes, the student at length
sitting down in a state of profuse perspiration, highly complimented by
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account