The Cornhill Magazine (Vol. I, No. 5, May 1860)Various
General
The Cornhill Magazine (Vol. I, No. 5, May 1860)
Various
England -- Periodicals; English literature -- Periodicals; Short stories, English -- Periodicals
Jewish types; but the tenth generation adds nothing to the evidence of
the first, nor the ten-thousandth to the tenth.
I believe that this fallacy, which destroys the whole value of the
Cuvierian argument, has not before been pointed out; and even now, you
may, perhaps, ask if the fixity of Species is not proved by the fact
that like produces like? So far from this, that it is only by the aid
of such a fact in organic nature that we can imagine _new_ species to
have arisen: in other words, those who believe in the variability of
Species, and the introduction of new forms by means of modification from
the old, always invoke the law of hereditary transmission as the means
of establishing accidental variations. Thus, let us suppose the Egyptian
king to have had one hundred dogs, all of them staghounds, and no other
form of dog to have existed at that time in that country; the dog species
would be represented by the staghound. These staghounds would transmit
to their offspring all their _specific characters_. But, as every one
knows, however much dogs may resemble each other, they always present
individual differences in size, colour, strength, intelligence, &c. Now,
if any one of these differences should happen to become marked, and to
increase by the intermarriage of two dogs similarly distinguished by the
marked peculiarity, this peculiarity would in time become established by
hereditary transmission, and would form the starting-point of a new race
of dogs—say the greyhound—unless it were obliterated by intermarriage
with dogs of the old type. In the former case, we should have two races
of dogs among the descendants of those figured on the Egyptian tombs; but
as one of these races would still preserve the original staghound type,
Cuvier would refer to _it_ as a proof that species had not varied. We, on
the other hand, should point to the greyhound as proof that animal forms
_are_ variable, and that a new form had arisen from modification of the
old.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account