The Cornhill Magazine (Vol. I, No. 5, May 1860)Various
General
The Cornhill Magazine (Vol. I, No. 5, May 1860)
Various
England -- Periodicals; English literature -- Periodicals; Short stories, English -- Periodicals
It will not be expected that in these brief and desultory remarks
I should touch on all, or nearly all, the important points in the
discussion respecting the Fixity of Species. Mr. Darwin’s book is in
everybody’s hands, and my object has been to facilitate, if possible,
the comprehension of his book, and the adoption of a more philosophical
hypothesis, by pointing out the weakness of the chief argument on the
other side. There is one more argument which may be noticed—the more so
as it is constantly adduced with triumph by the one school, and admitted
as a difficulty by the other. Its force is so great that it prevents
many from accepting the development hypothesis. It is the argument
founded on the alleged impossibility of Hybrids continuing the race.
More than two or three generations of Hybrids, it is said, can never be
maintained; after that, the new form perishes: thus clearly showing how
Nature repudiates such amalgamations, and keeps her species jealously
distinct and invariable. This argument is held to be the touchstone of
the doctrine of species. I wish it were so; because, in that case, the
question would no longer be one of hypothesis, since we have now the
indubitable proof that some Hybrids _are_ fertile unto the thirteenth
generation and onwards.
A history of the various attempts which have been made to prove and
disprove the fertility of Hybrids, would lead us beyond our limits; the
curious reader is referred to the works cited below.[15] One decisive
case alone shall be given here, and no one will dispute that it _is_
decisive.
The hare (_lepus timidus_) is assuredly of a distinct species from the
rabbit (_lepus cuniculus_). So distinct are these species, that any
classification which should range them as one, would violate every
accepted principle. The hare is solitary, the rabbit gregarious; the hare
lives on the surface of the earth, the rabbit burrows under the surface;
the hare makes her home among the bushes, the rabbit makes a sort of nest
for her young in her burrow—keeping them there till they are weaned; the
hare has reddish-brown flesh, the rabbit white flesh; while the odour
exhaled by each, and the flavour of each, are unmistakeably different.
The hare has many anatomical characters differing from those of the
rabbit: such as greater length and strength of the hind legs, larger
body, shorter intestine, thicker skin, firmer hair, and different colour.
The hare breeds only twice or thrice a year, and at each litter has only
two or four; the rabbit will breed eight times a year, and each time has
four, six, seven, and even eight young ones. Finally, the two are violent
foes: the rabbits always destroy the hares, and all sportsmen are aware
that if the rabbits be suffered to multiply on an estate, there will be
small chance of hares.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account