The Cornhill Magazine (vol. XLII, no. 251 new series, May 1917)Various
History
The Cornhill Magazine (vol. XLII, no. 251 new series, May 1917)
Various
England -- Periodicals; English literature -- Periodicals; Short stories, English -- Periodicals
Briefly then, we see in this record of women’s service, which is coming
as a surprise to many, an instance wherein the pragmatic philosophy has
come to its own. In the early days of the Crimean War the people who were
‘afraid of experience, afraid of life,’ were shocked at the initiative
of Florence Nightingale. No really ‘nice’ women, they said, would want
to go out to nurse soldiers. The incredible insults heaped upon the
first women doctors are remembered by many to-day. The advocates of the
‘movement’ were charged at every new departure with the desire to change
the character of woman herself, whereas all that has been changed is
her position in the national life; and that change has undoubtedly been
rendered more conspicuous since the war.
To all reasonable persons, whether pragmatists or not, the record of
experience is worth a great deal of theory. There are many cautious but
fair-minded people who have regarded women’s capacity for difficult
administrative offices as unproven until now. There are many more who
would have hastily judged them unfit for the responsible work which they
are doing in the aircraft and munition departments. For all such there
is a message in the principle of pragmatism. ‘It preserves,’ says its
genial apologist, ‘a cordial relation with facts.... The pragmatist turns
towards concreteness and adequacy, towards facts, towards action and
towards power.... That means the open air and possibilities of nature as
against dogma, artificiality and the pretence of finality in truth.’
And Truth, to quote again from a former passage, can just now be vividly
observed ‘in the making’ in the great workshop of the world. She can
be caught in the grip of the philosopher, and submitted to the most
searching inquiry which the mind of man can desire: she can be traced
through the past, as Green desired to trace her, to her eternal source
in the ‘ideas’ which are a ‘basis for human effort’: she can be brought
to the bar of Reality. In this way, it may be added, the method of
Pragmatism may exercise a wholesome bracing effect upon one’s thought. It
clears away the cobwebs of abstractions; it watches Truth at its daily
work in particulars whence only careful generalisations should be drawn.
It brings all theory to the test of experiment. And finally recurring
to our starting point, it lays stress upon the power of every idea in
action, insisting upon the vital correlation of thought and deed. For in
the words of the old Greek dramatist,[5] ‘The word and the deed should be
present as one thing, to dispatch that end whereto the counselling mind
moveth.’
LESLIE KEENE.
FOOTNOTES
[5] Aeschylus.
_THE BRITISH RED CROSS IN ITALY._
BY LEWIS R. FREEMAN.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account