The personal failings of Mohammed seem to have brought into his creed a
blight of cruelty, bigotry, and self-indulgence, which has rendered
half-useless its higher and nobler features. The religion which
legalises the slaughter and plunder of all unbelievers and consigns
woman to the harem may have been a comparative blessing to the wild
Arabs of Mohammed’s own day, or to the Negro of the modern Soudan: to
the civilised world it was a mere curse—the substitution of an inferior
for a higher creed and life. Even to the Arab of the seventh century it
was but half-beneficial: if it stayed him from drunkenness, human
sacrifices, and infanticide, it merely directed his bloodthirstiness
against foreign instead of domestic foes, and gave a divine sanction to
many of his lower instincts. [Sidenote: Failings of Islam.] Wherever
Mohammedanism has taken root, it has led at first to rapid and
enthusiastic outbursts of vigour, but it seems gradually to sap the
energy of the nations which adopt it, and leads, after a few generations
of greatness, to a stagnation and decay, which the Moslem in his
self-satisfied bigotry is too blind to perceive. The creed only thrives
while militant. When it has won its victory, it sinks into dull apathy.
Islam is a good religion to die by, as its fanatics have shown on a
thousand battle-fields, but not a good religion to live by. Good and
evil elements are too hopelessly mixed in it, just as in Mohammed’s
Koran, that miscellaneous receptacle of all his revelations: high
thoughts about the Godhead or the fate of man are mingled with the mere
opportunist orders of the day, or with licences for the personal
gratification of the Prophet.[35]
Footnote 35:
The Koran consists of all Mohammed’s inspired sayings, taken down at
the time on wooden tablets, palm-leaves, or blade-bones, by his
followers, and consigned in confusion to a chest, from which they were
afterwards drawn out at random, and strung together, not according to
their date or their contents, but simply in order of length.
But whatever were the failings of Mohammed and of Mohammed’s creed, they
had one fearful efficiency, the power to turn their sectaries into wild
fanatics, careless of life or death upon the battle-field. Life meant to
them the duty of smiting down the Infidel, and the privilege of spoiling
him: death, the yet greater joys of a paradise of gross sensual
delights. What the first mad rush of a horde of Moslem fanatics, drunk
with religious frenzy, was like, modern Europe had half forgotten,
though our crusading forefathers knew it well enough. But the generation
which has seen the half-armed Arabs of the Soudan face the steadiest
troops in the world equipped with quick-firing rifles and artillery, and
almost carry the day against them, has had good reason to revise its
view about the power of Mohammedan fanaticism.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account