The Disputed V.C.: A Tale of the Indian MutinyGibbon, Frederick P.
History
The Disputed V.C.: A Tale of the Indian Mutiny
Gibbon, Frederick P.
India -- History -- Sepoy Rebellion, 1857-1858 -- Juvenile fiction
"Yes, so can I," the colonel agreed. "Ted and Ambar Singh might easily
have been mistaken, and have misjudged him."
When Leigh had finished recording the evidence, Major Munro asked Tynan
to retire for a few moments. He then questioned Dwarika Rai as to who
laid the powder train.
"Russell Sahib, I think," was the reply.
"Did you notice Tynan Sahib enter the magazine?"
"Yes, sahib, before they battered the door in. He was away some time,
and I wondered why."
The major turned to his colleagues and observed in English:
"Tynan's tale is true so far;" and the others nodded assent.
"Tell us, then," asked Leigh, "is it true that Tynan Sahib tried to
prevent Russell Sahib firing the train?"
"In short," said the deputy-commissioner, "did Ensign Tynan act as an
officer or as a coward?"
"Nay," the man earnestly replied, "I do not like Tynan Sahib overmuch,
greatly preferring Russell Sahib, but he was not a coward. He was very
much excited, as we all were, and he tried to snatch the candle from his
comrade's hand. But I thought they were contesting who should light the
train, as if it matters who did it. The important thing is that it was
done."
The Englishmen whispered together, and presently Munro said: "You may
go, Dwarika Rai."
"I must say," began Colonel Woodburn, "his evidence confirms Tynan's in
every important respect. I'm afraid we've done the lad a serious
injustice."
"Yet his account differs from Russell's in point of actual fact, not
merely in the interpretation put upon facts," the deputy-commissioner
argued.
"Ted was probably excited, and the shock may have temporarily affected
his memory," Leigh suggested.
"Ted is certainly to blame," said Munro. "He may easily have mistaken
Tynan's excitement for terror."
Said Leigh:
"We forget. Ted Russell never accused Tynan of cowardice. That was Ambar
Singh."
"But Ted did not deny it," said Munro, "and he ought to have done so.
But when asked, he did state implicitly that the suggestion was wholly
his. Either he or Tynan is lying. We must have a full enquiry, and
meanwhile Tynan must be treated as 'not guilty' of cowardice."
"My humble opinion," said Leigh thoughtfully, "is that I'd believe Ted
Russell's word against Tynan's oath. I don't understand it."
Had he seen Dwarika Rai's cheerful nod, as, returning to the men's
quarters, he passed Ensign Tynan, he might have understood it better.
The havildar was a brave and loyal fellow, but he was a Hindu with a
Hindu's respect for truth. Tynan, returning after the first interview
with his superior officers, had almost run into Dwarika Rai as he
entered the men's quarters. The surprise was great on both sides.
"I'm done for," was the first thought of our unscrupulous ensign. "This
fellow will knock my tale on the head." His next was: "Why not bribe him
to confirm what I have said?"
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account