The scope of Irish scholarship may in some measure be judged from the
existing works of the great and better-known scholars mentioned in
this and other chapters, but the precise influence of that scholarship
is more difficult to estimate. It is only in very recent years that
we have begun to realise how much native Irish literature and history
owes to the Irish monastic schools. In the wider field of European
scholarship there is still much room for investigation before we can
confidently assign to Irish monastic scholarship its proper place.
The superiority of Irish classical learning has been demonstrated
and is now acknowledged by practically all scholars who have made an
intensive study of the early Middle Ages.[536] But as a discerning
historian has remarked, “what is of greatest significance is the fact
that there reigned not only among the professed scholars but among
the plain missionaries (whose name was legion) a classical spirit, a
love of literature for its own sake and a keen delight in poetry. They
brought imagination, they brought spiritual force to a world well nigh
sunk in materialism.... Their lighter productions show but one side of
their Scottish nature. Their earnest single pursuit of learning in the
widest sense attainable, their solid hard work as scholars is no less
characteristic. Ireland was once the university not only of Northern
England, but of the Frankish realm and if that progress was arrested
after the fatal inroads of the Norsemen after 795 A.D. the seed which
the Scots had sown in other lands grew to a nobler maturity than
ever it reached on its own soil.... Wherever they went they founded
schools.”[537]
Many other tributes to Irish monastic scholarship might be quoted.
We have selected but two of these partly because of the weight of
authority rightly associated with the author’s name in each case and
partly because they summarise the detailed evidence we have presented
during the course of our study.
Turner says: “The Irish teachers left a lasting impression on their own
and succeeding generations. Not only were they the chief teachers of
grammar, poetry, astronomy, music, and geography when these branches
had no other, or scarcely any other, representative on the continent
of Europe, but they also profoundly influenced the course of mediæval
thought in matters of philosophy and theology. Their elucidation of the
Gospel of St. John and their commentaries on the Epistles of St. Paul
formed a new school of exegesis.... They introduced the Neo-Platonic
point of view in metaphysical speculation and carried the art of
dialectic to a higher point than it ever before attained. It is no
exaggeration to say that they were the founders of scholasticism and
that Ireland is the Ionia of mediæval philosophy.”[538]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account