The Earth's BeginningBall, Robert S. (Robert Stawell)
Science
The Earth's Beginning
Ball, Robert S. (Robert Stawell)
Krakatoa (Indonesia); Nebular hypothesis
There can be no doubt that either of these two systems would be possible
for thousands of revolutions. There is nothing whatever to prevent A and
B from being started in the same direction round the sun as in the first
figure, or with A in one direction and B in the opposite direction, as
in the second figure. It is equally conceivable that, while A and B
revolve in the same direction, both should be opposite to that of the
sun. But one system is permanent, and the other is not.
For, as a matter of fact, we do not find in Nature such an arrangement
as that in the second figure, or as that in which both the planets
revolve in opposite directions to the sun’s rotation; what we do find
is, that the planets go round in the same direction as the sun. And the
explanation is undoubtedly connected with the important principle
already illustrated, namely, that natural systems are in a condition in
which the total quantity of energy undergoes continuous reduction in
comparison with the moment of momentum.
In the arrangements made in the two figures, it will be recollected that
the masses of the three bodies were respectively the same, and also
their distances apart, and their velocities. As the energy depends only
on the masses, the distances, and the velocities, the energies of the
two systems must be identical. But the moment of momentum of the two
systems is very different, for while in the one case the sum of the
moments of momentum of the sun’s rotation and that of the planet A,
which is going in the same direction, are to be _increased_ by the
moment of momentum of B, the same is not the case in the other system.
The moment of momentum of the sun and of A conspire, no doubt, and must
be added together; but as B is revolving in the opposite direction, the
moment of momentum of this planet has to be subtracted before we obtain
the nett moment of momentum of the system. Hence, we perceive a
remarkable difference between the two systems; for, though in each the
total energy is the same, yet in the latter case the moment of momentum
is smaller than in the former.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account