The Earth's BeginningBall, Robert S. (Robert Stawell)
Science
The Earth's Beginning
Ball, Robert S. (Robert Stawell)
Krakatoa (Indonesia); Nebular hypothesis
I represent, in the diagram shown in Fig. 23, three consecutive beds of
rock—A, B, and C—as they lie in the earth’s crust, a little more than a
mile beneath our feet. I shall suppose that the bed B is the very lowest
rock whose temperature was determined in the great boring. The drill has
passed completely through A, it has pierced to the middle of B, but it
has not entered C. The observations have shown that the temperature of
the stratum B exceeds that of the stratum A, and we further note that
this is a permanent condition—that is to say, B constantly remains
hotter than A. From this fact alone we can learn something as regards
the temperature of the stratum C which lies in contact with B. Of course
we are unable to observe the temperature of C directly, because by
hypothesis the boring tool has not entered that rock. We can, however,
prove, from the laws of the conduction of heat, that the temperature of
C must be greater than that of B; and this appears from the following
consideration.
[Illustration: Fig. 23.—AT THE BOTTOM OF THE GREAT BORE.]
It is plain that C must be either just the same temperature as B, or it
must be hotter than B, or it must be colder than B. If C were the same
temperature as B, then the law of conduction of heat tells us that no
heat would flow from one of these strata to the other. The laws of heat,
however, assure us that when two bodies at different temperatures are in
contact the heat will flow from the hotter of these bodies into the
colder, so long as the inequality of temperature is maintained. As B is
hotter than A, then heat must necessarily flow from B into A, and this
flow must tend to equalise the temperature in these strata, for B is
losing heat while none is flowing into it from C. Therefore B and A
could not continue to preserve indefinitely the different temperatures
which observation shows them to do. We are therefore forced to the
conclusion that B and C cannot be at the same temperature.
Next let us suppose that the temperature of the stratum B exceeded that
of C. Then, as A is colder than B, it appears that B would be lying
between two strata each having a temperature lower than itself. But
that, of course, cannot be a permanent arrangement, for the heat would
then escape from B on both sides. The laws of heat, therefore, tell us
that B could not possibly retain permanently a temperature above both A
and C. Observation, however, shows that the temperatures of A and B are
persistently unequal. We are therefore obliged to reject the supposition
that the temperature of C can be less than that of B.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account