The Education of American GirlsBrackett, Anna C. (Anna Callender)
General
The Education of American Girls
Brackett, Anna C. (Anna Callender)
Women -- Education -- United States
Again, therefore, it may be said, that wherever such intermittence is
not superfluous, it would be inadequate for the purpose for which it is
designed.
But this conclusion may seem to be much more severe, and, to those
interested in the education of girls, much more disagreeable than that
formulated by Dr. Clarke. We firmly believe, however, that truth never
can be disagreeable when it is really understood in all its bearings and
all its consequences, and conversely, that any proposition framed with a
view to supposed desirableness rather than veracity, is almost certain
to lead in the end to consequences quite undesirable. We will not,
therefore, try to decide whether it may be more agreeable to believe
that the health of adolescent girls requires general and permanent
supervision, or that all responsibility may be discharged by confining
them to a sofa and a novel for one week out of every four; to believe
that a certain number of women, as of men, are always unfit for
intellectual exertion, or that all women are inevitably rendered so
unfit during one quarter of their lives at times unknown to outsiders,
and which, therefore, may be at any time; to believe that the increased
delicacy of women in civilized societies depends on a cultivated
predominance of their ganglionic nervous system and emotional functions,
or on the excessive stimulus of the cerebro-spinal system and on
intellectual cultivation.
More useful than such discussion is the consideration of the methods
that might be proposed, instead of that suggested by Dr. Clarke in the
third proposition we have formulated from his book. Dr. Clarke's method
is to provide regular intermittences in the education of girls,
"conceding to Nature her moderate but inexorable demand for rest, during
one week out of four." The method that we believe to be suggested by the
foregoing considerations would be more complex, but, we think, at once
more effectual and less inconvenient. It may be stated in the following
formula: "Secure the predominance of the cerebro-spinal system over the
activity of the ganglionic." Since the activity of the cerebro-spinal
system may be roughly[46] divided into a twofold direction, intellectual
and muscular, this predominance is to be secured by assiduous
cultivation of the intellect as compared with the emotions, and of the
muscles of the limbs as compared with the muscular fibre of the
blood-vessels. In other words, the evil effects of school competition,
and of the emotional excitement natural to adolescence, are to be
combated by a larger, wider, slower, and more complete intellectual
education than at present falls to the lot of either boys or girls. And
the dangers incident to the development of new activity in the
ganglionic nervous system by the functions of the ovaries, the dangers
of irregular circulation, vaso-motor spasm and paralysis, are to be
averted by systematic physical exercise, that shall stimulate the spinal
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account