The electron, its isolation and measurement and the determination of some of its propertiesMillikan, Robert Andrews
Philosophy
The electron, its isolation and measurement and the determination of some of its properties
Millikan, Robert Andrews
Electrons
The evidence for the soundness of the conception of non-radiating
electronic orbits is to be looked for, then, first, in the success of
the constants involved, and, second, in the physical significance, if
any, which attaches to the third assumption. If these constants come
out right within the limits of experimental error, then the theory
of non-radiating electronic orbits has been given the most crucial
imaginable of tests, especially if these constants are accurately
determinable.
[Pg 214]
What are the facts? The constant of the Balmer series in hydrogen,
that is, the value of in equation (34), is known with the great
precision attained in all wave-length determinations and is equal to
. From the Bohr theory it is given by the
simplest algebra (Appendix G) as
As already indicated, in 1917 I redetermined[156] with an
estimated accuracy of one part in 1,000 and obtained for it the value
. As will be shown in the next chapter, I have
also determined photo-electrically[157] with an error, in the
case of sodium, of no more than one-half of 1 per cent, the value for
sodium, upon which I got the most reliable data, being .
The value found by Duane’s X-ray method,[158] which is
thought to yield a result correct to one part in 700, is exceedingly
close to mine, namely, . Substituting this
in (38), we get with the aid of Bucherer’s value of
(), which is probably correct to 0.1 per cent,
, which agrees within a fourth of 1
per cent with the observed value. This agreement constitutes
most extraordinary justification of the theory of non-radiating
electronic orbits. It demonstrates that the behavior of the negative
electron in the hydrogen atom is at least correctly described by the
equation of a circular non-radiating orbit. If this equation can
be obtained from some other physical condition than that of an actual
[Pg 215]
orbit, it is obviously incumbent upon those who so hold to show what
that condition is. Until this is done, it is justifiable to suppose
that the equation of an orbit means an actual orbit.
Again, the radii of the stable orbits for hydrogen are easily found
from Bohr’s assumptions to take the mathematical form (Appendix G)
In other words, since is a whole number, the radii of these
orbits bear the ratios 1, 4, 9, 16, 25. If normal hydrogen is assumed
to be that in which the electron is in the inmost possible orbit,
namely, that for which , the diameter of the normal
hydrogen atom, comes out . The best
determination for the diameter of the hydrogen molecule yields
in extraordinarily close agreement with the
prediction from Bohr’s theory.
[Pg 216]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account