The electron, its isolation and measurement and the determination of some of its propertiesMillikan, Robert Andrews
Philosophy
The electron, its isolation and measurement and the determination of some of its properties
Millikan, Robert Andrews
Electrons
Two very potent objections, however, may be urged against all forms
of ether-string theory. The first is that no one has ever yet been
able to show that such a theory can predict any one of the facts of
interference. The second is that there is direct positive evidence
against the view that the ether possesses a fibrous structure. For if
a static electrical field has a fibrous structure, as postulated by
any form of ether-string theory, “each unit of positive electricity
being the origin and each unit of negative electricity the termination
of a Faraday tube,”[179] then the force acting on one single
electron between the plates of an air condenser cannot possibly vary
continuously with the potential difference between the plates. Now in
the oil-drop experiments[180] we actually study the behavior in such an
electric field of one single, isolated electron and we find, over the
widest limits, exact proportionality between the field strength and the
force acting on the electron as measured by the velocity with which the
oil drop to which it is attached is dragged through the air.
When we maintain the field constant and vary the charge on the drop,
the granular structure of electricity is proved by the discontinuous
changes in the velocity, but when we maintain the charge constant
and vary the field the lack of discontinuous change in the velocity
disproves the contention of a fibrous structure in the field, unless
the assumption be made that there are an enormous number of ether
strings ending in one electron. Such an assumption takes most of the
virtue out of an ether-string theory.
[Pg 250]
Despite, then, the apparently complete success of the Einstein
equation, the physical theory of which it was designed to be the
symbolic expression is thus far so irreconcilable with a whole group
of well-established facts that some of the most penetrating of modern
physicists cannot as yet accept it, and we are somewhat in the position
of having built a very perfect structure and then knocked out entirely
the underpinning without causing the building to fall. It stands
complete and apparently well tested, but without any visible means of
support. These supports must obviously exist, and the most fascinating
problem of modern physics is to find them. Experiment has outrun
theory, or, better, guided by unacceptable theory, it has discovered
relationships which seem to be of the greatest interest and importance,
but the reasons for them are as yet not at all understood.
VII. ATTEMPTS TOWARD A SOLUTION
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account