(_e_) In institutional life, the children learn nothing of the vital
needs of daily life, or of the difficulties of the struggle for
existence; and yet it is all the more necessary that they should
learn something about these matters, inasmuch as in their subsequent
life they will presumably have a hard struggle for their daily bread.
Whatever the child really needs, it receives in the institution;
thus an idea arises in its mind that there is some higher power
which cares for all these things. The child has to make no effort,
no sacrifices are exacted from it; in the institution, tests of the
child’s power of resistance, such as might strengthen it to meet the
temptations of the outer world, are few and far between, for from the
temptations of the outer world it is sheltered by the walls of the
institution.
(_f_) The institution is not adapted to provide for the complete
education of a child--for the learning of a trade. It is absolutely
necessary that institutional care should be supplemented by work
under a master, in a technical school or teaching workshop.
(_g_) Institutional care is costlier than family care.
(_h_) Only family care can replace for a child the loss of its own
family. Family care is the only natural method of upbringing, whereas
the best possible institutional care is purely mechanical, full of
defects, and cannot possibly replace a free life. In a sense, the
institution is indeed a large family. But in the free life, outside
the particular family to which the child belongs, there are thousands
of others, communicating and competing with one another. No such
competition exists in the institution; the child’s work there is
purely mechanical, but as soon as it enters the open world, the child
has to seek work, and often fails to find it.
(_i_) The State lays down the principles in accordance with which
the foster-parents must bring up the child, and sees that the
foster-parents have access to expert advice concerning every
department of the hygiene of childhood. The State insists that
whenever necessary the foster-children shall have medical aid,
that the children shall attend the elementary school, &c. If the
foster-parents apply these principles properly in their care of
the foster-children, they are likely to take care that their own
children are treated at least equally well. And if, in any community,
these principles are applied cordially and intelligently by the
foster-parents, it is probable that the other parents of the same
community will follow this good example.
(_k_) Statistical data show, moreover, that family care gives better
results than institutional care, alike physically, mentally, and
morally.
(_l_) With regard to the alleged defects of family care (such as
that foster-children are less well treated than the foster-parents’
own children, that they are exploited by the foster-parents, that
suitable foster-parents are hard to find), these can readily be
overcome.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account