_Advantages and Disadvantages of Illegitimate Birth._--Three
different views prevail regarding the relative advantages and
disadvantages of illegitimate births. (1) Illegitimate children
come into the world favourably equipped, for their parents are
young, and their union depends not upon interest, but upon love.
(2) Illegitimate children are hereditarily defective, as is clearly
manifest in all relationships. Private statistical data show that in
respect of body-weight and body-length the illegitimate new-born,
boys as well as girls, compare unfavourably with the legitimate.
Many illegitimate children exhibit a disposition to various mental
disorders (degenerative neuroses and psychoses). Since in most cases
the father is unknown, and his qualities therefore elude observation,
there would appear to be some ground for the assumption that the
hereditary tainting of illegitimate children is even greater than it
is actually proved to be. (3) Illegitimate children come into the
world with the same equipment as legitimate children.
The first of these views is erroneous, if only for the reason that in
men often nothing more than sensuality, and in women often nothing
more than self-interest, leads to the formation of an irregular
sexual intimacy. But neither the second view nor the third can be
accepted without reserve. In interpreting the statistical data
relating to illegitimacy, many circumstances have to be considered.
Attention must always be paid to the question, which were the
intimacies in which the conditions were similar to those of married
life, and to the question as to the extent to which the peculiarities
apparent in the illegitimate are dependent solely upon the legal
disabilities of their status. The material conditions in which
illegitimate children are placed must be compared with those of
legitimate children belonging to similar social classes. It would
be altogether fallacious to compare the condition of illegitimate
children with the average condition of legitimate children, instead
of with the average condition of children of the proletariat. If
these considerations receive due attention, it will become apparent
that illegitimacy _per se_ is not a decisive factor, but merely
renders more apparent the disadvantages attendant on being brought up
under the conditions inevitable for the children of the proletariat.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account