_Criminality in the Illegitimate._--Private and official statistical
data combine to prove that in illegitimate children criminality is
considerably more common than it is in the legitimate. In individual
countries, and in respect of different criminal offences, the
relationships are very variable; but there is not a single civilised
country in which we fail to find that the average criminality-rate
of illegitimate children is considerably higher than the average
criminality-rate of the legitimate. We see this difference
maintained, alike in respect of the number of punishable offences
committed on the average by each convicted person, in respect of
particular offences in the case of those who experience only one
conviction, and finally in respect of the percentage of convicted
offenders among the two respective classes. Not a single punishable
offence can be mentioned, in respect of which we fail to find that
the percentage of illegitimates convicted of that offence is larger
than the percentage of legitimates so convicted. Moreover, if we
compare recidivists and major offenders with other criminals, we find
that the unfavourable influence of illegitimacy is especially marked
in the case of the former. The conclusions drawn from the criminal
statistics are confirmed by those obtained from reformatories and
similar institutions; everywhere we find a higher criminality-rate
among the illegitimate.
One circumstance, however, which is commonly overlooked, has to
be taken into account. Among those convicted of criminal offences,
a certain percentage are persons of illegitimate birth (_a_); a
certain percentage of all births are those of illegitimates (_b_); a
certain percentage of persons who have attained the age at which they
become legally liable to punishment for their actions are persons of
illegitimate birth (_c_). It is not the ratio between the numbers in
class (_a_) and the numbers in class (_b_) that we have to consider,
but the ratio between the numbers in class (_a_) and the numbers
in class (_c_). For the death-rate among illegitimate children is
much higher than the death-rate of the legitimate; and the number
of the illegitimate diminishes through legitimisation. Thus a much
smaller proportion of young persons and of adults consists of persons
of illegitimate birth than in the case of the new-born. The proper
method of comparison would be to ascertain whether the percentage
of illegitimate children at a certain age convicted of criminal
offences or undergoing education in a reformatory is greater than the
percentage of legitimate children of like age found to be undergoing
the same punishment or the same education.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account