The Energy System of Matter: A Deduction from Terrestrial Energy PhenomenaWeir, James, active 1883-1912
Science
The Energy System of Matter: A Deduction from Terrestrial Energy Phenomena
Weir, James, active 1883-1912
Force and energy
It is a somewhat remarkable fact that in this age of scientific reason
the observation of the strictly orderly arrangement of phenomena in the
solar system as a whole should not have led to some idea in the minds of
philosophical workers of a similar order of phenomena in its separate
parts, but the explanation lies generally in the continual attempts to
bring natural phenomena into line with certain preconceived hypotheses,
and more particularly to the almost universal acceptance of the doctrine
of the direct transmission of energy from the sun to the earth and the
final rejection or radiation of this energy into space. There is no
denying the eminent plausibility of this doctrine. The evidence of
Nature _prima facie_ may even appear to completely substantiate it. But
we would submit that the general circumstances in which this doctrine is
now so readily accepted are very similar to those which prevailed in
more ancient times, when the revolution of the sun and stars round the
earth was the universal tenet of natural philosophy. This conception,
allied to the belief that the sole function of the celestial bodies was
to provide light and heat to the terrestrial mass, appeared to be in
strict accordance with observed phenomena, and held undisturbed
possession of the minds of men for centuries, until it was finally
demolished by Copernicus as the result of simple and accurate
observation of and deduction from natural phenomena. At the present
time, the somewhat venerable belief in the transmission of energy in
various forms from the sun to the earth appears at first sight to be
supported by actual facts. But a more rigid scrutiny of the evidence and
of the mental processes must inevitably lead the unbiassed mind to the
conclusion that this belief has no real foundation on truly scientific
observation, but is entirely unsupported by natural phenomena. Every
operation of Nature, in fact, when considered in its true relationships
is an absolute denial of the whole conception. Like its predecessor
relating to the motion of the sun and stars round the earth, the
doctrine of energy transmission between separate masses in space such as
the sun and the earth cannot be sustained in the face of scientific
observation. This doctrine is found on investigation to be supported not
by phenomena but by the conception of an elastic ethereal medium, of
whose existence there is absolutely no evidential proof, and the
necessity for which disappears along with the hypothesis it supports. It
is, however, not proposed to discuss in any detail either the supposed
transmission of energy from the sun to the planets or the arbitrary
properties of the transmitting medium, but rather to adopt a more
positive method of criticism by summarising briefly the evidential
phenomena which show the cyclical nature of the whole terrestrial energy
process, and which remove the basis of belief in such a transmission.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account