The Energy System of Matter: A Deduction from Terrestrial Energy PhenomenaWeir, James, active 1883-1912
Science
The Energy System of Matter: A Deduction from Terrestrial Energy Phenomena
Weir, James, active 1883-1912
Force and energy
In this portion of the work it is proposed to investigate in the light
of known phenomena the possibility of energy transmission between
separate masses. As explained above, the term separate is here meant to
convey the idea of perfect isolation, and the only masses in Nature
which truly satisfy this condition are the celestial and planetary
bodies, separated as they are from one another by interplanetary space
and in virtue of their energised condition (§ 5). Since this state of
separation cannot be experimentally realised under terrestrial
conditions, it is obvious, therefore, that no purely terrestrial energy
process can be advanced either as direct verification or direct disproof
of a transmission of energy between such truly separate masses as the
celestial bodies. But as we are unable to experiment directly on these
bodies themselves or across interplanetary space, we are forced of
necessity to rely, for experimental facts and conclusions, on the
terrestrial energy phenomena to which access is possible. As already
indicated in the General Statement (§ 11), the same energy is bestowed
on all parts of the cosmical system, and by the close observation of the
phenomena of its action in familiar operations the truest guidance may
be obtained as to its general nature and working. In such
investigations, however, only the actual phenomena of the operation are
of scientific or informative value. There is no gain to real knowledge
in assuming, say in the examination of the phenomena of magnetic
attraction between two bodies, that the one is urged towards the other
by stresses in an intervening ethereal medium, when absolutely no
phenomenal evidence of the existence of such a medium is available. It
may be urged that the conception of an ethereal medium is adapted to the
explanation of phenomena, and appears in many instances to fulfil this
function. But as already pointed out (see Introduction), it is
absolutely impossible to explain phenomena. So-called explanations must
ever resolve themselves simply into revelations of further phenomena.
While the value of true working hypotheses cannot be denied, it is
surely evident that such hypotheses, unless they embody and are under
the limitation of controlling facts, are not only useless, but, from the
misleading ideas they are apt to convey, may even be dangerous factors
in the search for truth. Now, if all speculative ideas or hypotheses are
banished from the mind, and reliance is placed solely on the evidential
phenomena of Nature, the study of terrestrial energy operations leads
inevitably to certain conclusions on the question of energy
transmission. In the first place, it must lead to the denial of what has
been virtually the great primary assumption of modern science, namely,
that a mass of material at a high temperature isolated in interplanetary
space would radiate heat in all directions through that space. Such a
conception is unsupported by our experimental or real knowledge of
radiation.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account