The Energy System of Matter: A Deduction from Terrestrial Energy PhenomenaWeir, James, active 1883-1912
Science
The Energy System of Matter: A Deduction from Terrestrial Energy Phenomena
Weir, James, active 1883-1912
Force and energy
The fact that heat radiation takes place from a hot to a cold
body in whatever direction the latter is placed relatively to the
former, does not justify the assumption that such radiation takes place
in all directions in the absence of a cold body. And since there is
absolutely no manifestation of any real material medium occupying
interplanetary space, no sign of the material agency or machine which
the results of direct experiment have led us to conclude is a necessity
for the transmission process of heat radiation, the whole conception
must be regarded as at least doubtful. Even with our limited knowledge
of radiation, the doctrine of heat radiation through space stands
controverted by ordinary experimental experience. With this doctrine
must fall also the allied conception of the transmission of heat energy
by radiation from the sun to the earth. It is to be noted, however, that
only the actual transmission of heat energy from the sun to the earth is
inadmissible; the _heating effect_ of the sun on the earth, which leads
to the manifestation of terrestrial energy in the heat form, is a
continuous operation readily explained in the light of the general
principle of energy transformation already enunciated (§ 4). With
respect to other possible processes of energy transmission between the
sun and the earth or across interplanetary space, the same general
methods of experimental investigation must be adopted. The transmission
of energy under terrestrial conditions is carried out in many different
forms and by the working of a large variety of machines. In every case,
no matter in what form the energy is transmitted, that energy must be
associated with a definite arrangement of terrestrial material
constituting the transmission machine. Each energy process of
transmission has its own peculiar conditions of operation which must be
completely satisfied. By the study of these conditions and the allied
phenomena it is possible to gain a real knowledge of the precise
circumstances in which the process can be carried out. Now let us apply
the knowledge of transmission processes thus gained to the general
celestial case, to the question of energy transmission between truly
separate bodies, and particularly to the case of the sun and the earth.
Do we find in this case any evidence of the presence of a machine for
energy transmission? It is impossible, within the limits of this work,
to deal with all the forms in which energy may be transmitted, but let
the reader review any instance of the transmission of energy under
terrestrial conditions, or any energy-transmission machine with which he
is familiar, noting particularly the essential phenomena and material
arrangements, and let him ask himself if there is any evidence of the
existence of a machine of this kind in operation between the sun and
the earth or across interplanetary space. We venture to assert that the
answer must be in the negative. The real knowledge of terrestrial
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account