The English Prison SystemRuggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
History
The English Prison System
Ruggles-Brise, Evelyn, Sir
Prisons -- Great Britain
All these conceptions are regarded as due to a fixed conventional
idea that there was a 'normal' man, who led a good life, and an
'abnormal' man who led a bad life, and this misconception is held to
have stood in the way of a scientific view of the nature of criminal
man. "Scientifically," according to Dr. Goring, "we can only divide men
into 'normal' and 'abnormal' when there is some qualitative difference.
'Normal' is the outcome of the natural laws of existence. This becomes
'abnormal' only when supplanted by some pathological process. Normal
never 'merges' into the abnormal, _e.g._, the natural ranges of
vesicular breathing, of normal temperature, of folly, and want of
control, never merge into the morbid ranges of pneumonic breathing,
fevers and madness. The qualities that have to be considered in
relation to crime are not 'abnormal' qualities, but qualities common
to all humanity. Law-breakers are not a special breed of human beings
differing _qualitatively_ from those who keep the law: any difference
there may be between these two human classes is of degree only and
not of kind: and, similarly, law-breaking is not different in quality
from all other forms of anti-social conduct for which men are not
punished, even if they are found out: yet here again there is a vast
range of difference in _degree_. And that is why statistical methods
are necessary for the scientific study of the criminal. For only by
measurement can difference of degree be evaluated; and statistics is
merely a refined instrument for making measurements."
The word 'criminal,' strictly-speaking, only designates the fact that
an individual has been imprisoned: that he has committed a crime. The
object of this inquiry is to determine whether certain constitutional,
as well as environmental, factors play a part in the production of the
criminal act. It is impossible to state dogmatically _à priori_ what
these factors are, or which of them prevail in the determination of
a given act, but it is lawful to assume from the phenomenon of crime
that there is a hypothetical character of some kind, a constitutional
proclivity, either mental, moral or physical, present, to a certain
degree, in all individuals, but so potent in some as to determine for
them the fate of imprisonment.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account