The Ethics of Diet: A Catena of Authorities Deprecatory of the Practice of Flesh EatingWilliams, Howard
Philosophy
The Ethics of Diet: A Catena of Authorities Deprecatory of the Practice of Flesh Eating
Williams, Howard
Diet; Vegetarianism
“The man who, accustomed to live on roots and vegetables, first
devoured the flesh of the smallest mammal, committed a greater
violence to his own nature than the most beautiful and delicate
woman, accustomed to other animal flesh, would feel in shedding
the blood of her own species for sustenance; possessed as they are
of exquisite feelings, a considerable degree of intelligence, and
even, according to her own religious system, of a _living soul_.
That this is a principle in the social disposition of mankind,
is evident from the deliberate coolness with which seamen, when
their ordinary provisions are exhausted, sit down to devour such
of their comrades as chance or contrivance renders the victim of
the moment; a fact of which there are but too many, and those too
well-authenticated instances. Such a crime, which no necessity
can justify, would never enter the mind of a starving Gentoo,
nor, indeed, of anyone who had not been previously accustomed to
other animal flesh. Even among the Bedouins, or wandering Arabs
of the desert--according to the observation of the enlightened
Volney--though they so often experience the extremity of hunger,
the practice of devouring human flesh was never heard of.”
In the two following chapters Ritson traces a large proportion of human
diseases and suffering, physical and mental, to indulgence in unnatural
living. He cites Drs. Buchan, Goldsmith, Cheyne, Stubbes (_Anatomy of
Abuses_, 1583), and Sparrman the well-known pupil of Linné (_Voyages_).
In his ninth chapter, he gives a copious catalogue of “nations and of
individuals, past and contemporary, subsisting entirely upon vegetable
foods”--not the least interesting part of his work. Some of the most
eminent of the old Greek and Latin philosophers and historians are
quoted, as well as various modern travellers, such as Volney and
Sparrman. Especially valuable are the enquiries of Sir F. M. Eden
(_State of the Poor_), who, in a comparison of the dietary of the
poor, in different parts of these islands, proves that flesh has, or
at all events _had_, scarcely any share in it--a fact which is still
true of the agricultural districts, manifest not only by the commonest
observation, but also by scientific and official enquiries of late
years.
Of individual cases, two of the most interesting are those of John
Williamson of Moffat, the discoverer of the famous chalybeate spring,
who lived almost to the age of one hundred years, having abstained
from all flesh-food during the last fifty years of his life,[213] and
of John Oswald, the author of _The Cry of Nature_. It is in this part
of his work that Ritson narrates the history of his own conversion and
dietetic experiences, and of his well-known publisher, Mr. R. Phillips.
XXXVI.
NICHOLSON. 1760-1825.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account