The Ethics of Medical Homicide and MutilationO'Malley, Austin
Religion
The Ethics of Medical Homicide and Mutilation
O'Malley, Austin
Medical ethics
Pneumonia in pregnancy is made worse by the mechanical
interference with respiration brought about by the enlargement
of the uterus, and the heart, which is overburdened in ordinary
pneumonia, is still more exhausted by the additional strain
of pregnancy in the pneumonia of gestation; moreover, the
lungs, which are obliged to do enhanced labor in pregnancy
in eliminating, are clogged by the pneumonia; it would seem,
then, that, if the fetus is viable, the womb should be emptied
to give the mother a better chance for recovery. Statistics,
however, are against therapeutic abortion. The evacuation of
the uterus determines blood to the inflamed lungs, which are
already overburdened. The exhaustion of labor weakens the
patient, and makes her liable to general septic infection.
Matton[144] found that in eighteen cases where pregnancy was
artificially interrupted, nine women died (50 per cent.); while
in twenty cases where no interference was attempted, only one
woman died. This comparison is not exact, perhaps, because we
do not know the gravity of the infection in each group, but
in any consideration the difference is remarkable. In a group
studied by Chatelain[145] the results in natural and artificial
delivery were virtually the same. Inasmuch as therapeutic
abortion at the best is no better than non-interference, there
is no justification for therapeutic abortion, unless in unusual
circumstances.
[144] _Jour. de Méd. de Bruxelles_, 1872, p. 412.
[145] _Ibid._, 1870, vol. l, pp. 430, 516, and vol. li, p. 11.
Pneumonia is an infectious disease, and a pregnant woman should,
for her own sake and the sake of the fetus, avoid exposure to
infection. When the disease is present the last sacraments should not
be deferred, as it may be impossible to make a confession when near
death.
Influenza in pregnancy is more severe than it is in the non-gravid
state. By the laity, and sometimes even by physicians, influenza
is confused with la grippe, but there is an influenza vera and an
influenza nostras, or la grippe, and this latter is not nearly
so serious a disease. The real influenza is caused by a specific
bacillus; it appears in epidemics which have a tendency to become
pandemic, and then the disease disappears for a generation. La grippe
is a bronchitis or coryza with some fever and muscle-soreness. True
influenza (the name is Italian, _influenza di freddo_) is very
infectious. The pandemic of 1889-90 started in Turkestan in June,
1889, and by October, 1890, influenza had gone westward and encircled
the earth along the trade routes. The preceding pandemic occurred in
1847-48.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account