The Ethics of Medical Homicide and MutilationO'Malley, Austin
Religion
The Ethics of Medical Homicide and Mutilation
O'Malley, Austin
Medical ethics
Any kind of monster coming from the human womb, if it is only a
head and lacks a body (Acardiacus Acormus), or is a body and lacks
a head and heart (Acardiacus Acephalus), or is a Foetus Anideus,
which is a shapeless mass of flesh covered with skin, should be
baptized, provided _it shows signs of life_. Number 19 in the Ritual
would be liable to an interpretation which is too narrow if it were
not that very monstrous fetuses, which appear to a lay observer to
be not human, are as a rule delivered dead. Here it may be worth
while to mention that a hybrid between a human being and a lower
animal is impossible. As to number 20, the rule for differentiating
unity or duality of personality is not the number of heads, but the
number of evident consciousnesses, and this differentiation commonly
cannot be made at birth. There have been examples of two-headed
monsters delivered alive, which were single as to soul because the
consciousness evidently was one.
CHAPTER IV
WHEN DOES HUMAN LIFE END?
The moment human life begins in the human fetus is a subject of
dispute, but the moment human life ends is a mystery--we have no
method of determining exactly just when the soul leaves the body.
Daily throughout the world the priest reaches a patient who has just
died. Conditional absolution, extreme unction, baptism might have
been administered if there were signs of life, but the heart and
lungs are still, "the patient is dead," and the priest leaves without
doing anything. Yet it is always probable that the patient does not
die at once even in a case of decapitation.
Bichat, at the beginning of the last century, called the brain,
lungs, and heart "the tripod of life," and from time immemorial we
have based our judgment of the presence of somatic death on the lack
of consciousness, respiration, and circulation in the patient. The
heart, however, beats after consciousness and respiration cease (and
sometimes respiration continues after the pulse cannot be felt), and
this cardiac activity may go on for more than a half hour after all
the normal clinical signs of death have appeared--after respiration
has quit, when no heart-sounds can be heard by the stethoscope and
muscular relaxation indicates death.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account