The Evolution of StatesRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
History
The Evolution of States
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Europe -- Politics and government; Great Britain -- Politics and government; Political science -- History
As medical knowledge advanced, it seems certain, the practice of
abortion must have been generally added to that of infanticide in
Greece, as later in Rome. See Aristotle, _Politics_, vii, 16;
Plutarch, _Lycurgus_, c. 3; and Plato, _Theætetus_, p. 149
(Jowett's trans. iv, 202), as to the normal resort to abortion. The
Greeks must have communicated to the Romans the knowledge of the
arts of abortion, as they did those of medicine generally. But it
does not appear that with all these checks population really fell
off in Greece until after the time of Alexander. Before that time
it may very well have fallen off in Athens when she lost her
position as sovereign and tribute-drawing State. The tribute would
tend to maintain a population in excess of the natural amount. Dr.
Mahaffy (_Rambles and Studies in Greece_, 4th ed. p. 11--a passage
not squared with the data in _Greek Life and Thought_, pp. 328,
558) accepts the old view of a general and inexplicable
depopulation. One of the _loci classici_ on that head, in the
treatise _On the Cessation of Oracles_ (viii) attributed to
Plutarch but probably not by him, is searchingly examined by Hume
at the close of his essay _Of the Populousness of Ancient Nations_,
and the critic comes to the conclusion that the extreme decay there
asserted cannot have taken place. He was in all probability right
in arguing that the number of slaves in Attica had been enormously
exaggerated in the figures of Athenæus (cp. Cunningham, _Western
Civilisation_, i, 109, note). There is reason to conclude, however,
that Hume was unduly incredulous on some points. Strabo (refs. in
Thirlwall, viii, 460) had found an immense decay of population in
Greece more than a century before Plutarch; and his details prove a
process of shrinkage which must have lasted long. In any case, a
relative depopulation took place after the conquests of Alexander,
from the operation of socio-economic causes, which are indicated by
Finlay (_History of Greece_, Tozer's ed. i, 15; cp. Mahaffy, _Greek
Life and Thought_, p. 328, and _The Greek World under Roman Sway_,
1890, p. 218). Broadly speaking, the Greeks went to lands where
wealth was more easily acquired than in their own. Further
depopulation took place under the Romans, partly from direct
violence and deportation, partly from fiscal pressure, partly from
the economic causes already noted.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account