For instance, it might have been predicted from the theory alone that
an immune species would often have several mimics, as, in point of
fact, is frequently the case, and it would be easy to give numerous
examples of this. Thus the two Danaids of South and Central Africa,
_Amauris echeria_ and _Amauris niavius_, are mimicked, not only
by the two female forms of _Papilio merope_, as we have already
described in detail, but the latter is also mimicked by Nymphalid,
which requires protection, _Diadema anthedon_, and the former by two
diurnal butterflies of different families, _Diadema nuina_ and _Papilio
echerioides_.
Similarly, the black-and-red coloured _Heliconius melpomene_ in Brazil
is mimicked both by the female of a White (_Archonias teuthamis_),
and by a _Papilio_, which has received the name of _P. euterpinus_ on
account of this resemblance. Thus, too, the immune _Methona psidii_,
Cr. of Brazil, with its half-transparent wings marked with black bands,
has five mimics, belonging to five different genera, and one of these
is not a true diurnal butterfly at all, but one of the day-flying
species of the genus _Castnia_, whose systematic position is doubtful.
[Illustration: FIG. 18. Upper surfaces of _A_, _Acræa egina_, from the
Gold Coast, immune. _B_, _Papilio ridleyanus_, from Gaboon, not immune.
_C_, _Pseudacræa boisduvalii_, from the Gold Coast, not immune.]
The West African immune Acræid, _Acræa gea_ (Pl. II, Fig. 21), is
deceptively mimicked, both as to the narrow, long shape of the wing
and its blackish-brown and white mottled markings, by a Nymphalid,
_Pseudacræa hirce_, by the female of a Papilio (_P. cynorta_) whose
mate is quite different, and by the female of a Satyrid (_Elymnias
phegea_) (Pl. II, Fig. 20). In the _Papilio_ the resemblance extends to
the peculiar pitch-black shining spot on the under side of the base of
the posterior wing, and all three are like the model on both surfaces,
and therefore in flight as well as in the resting attitude.
On the same West African coast occurs the strange greyish-black _Acræa
egina_, with brick-red spots and bands, and coal-black dots (Fig. 18,
_A_). This immune species is deceptively mimicked in its native country
by two other butterflies--a Nymphalid, _Pseudacræa boisduvalii_ (Fig.
18, _C_), and by a female _Papilio_ (_P. ridleyanus_) (Fig. 18, _B_),
by the latter not so exactly as by the former, but quite sufficiently
to be confused with its model in flight.
It would have been less easy to predict with certainty from the theory
that, conversely, the different species of a genus which stood in need
of protection would be able to mimic quite different immune models, for
who would have ventured to prophesy how far the capacity of a species
for variation might go, and how many different kinds of coloration it
was able to assume? But the facts teach us that there is a wide range
of possibility in this respect.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account