The fact that highly developed specific talents have never been known
to be inherited through more than seven generations is quite in keeping
with this view. But even this persistence has been observed only in
the case of musical talent, and the long continuance of the inherited
talent may well be due, as Francis Galton suggests in his famous
statistical investigations into the phenomena of inheritance, to the
fact that musical men do not readily choose wives who are absolutely
lacking in this talent. It would be easy to rear an exceedingly
highly gifted musical group of families within the German nation, if
we could secure that only the highly-gifted musically should unite
in marriage--that is, if personal selection could play its part. In
another more general domain of mental endowment a case of this kind
has been recorded, for Galton tells us of three highly gifted English
families which intermarried for ten generations, and in that time
scarcely produced a descendant who did not deserve to be called a
distinguished man in some direction or other.
Of course, such continued persistence, through a long series of
generations, of a high general mental level is more possible than the
transmission and increase of a specific talent, for in the former case
it is a question of a mixture of different high mental endowments,
of which not all need be developed in every individual, and yet the
individual need not fall to mediocrity if he possesses a combination
of other qualities. But in musical talent, on the other hand, the
falling from the height once attained takes place as soon as this one
character is no longer represented in a sufficiently strong majority
of determinants. Of course it would be a mistake to believe that the
talent of a Sebastian Bach or a Beethoven depended solely on the
highly developed musical sense; in them, as in all great artists, many
highly developed mental qualities must have combined with the musical
sense; a simpleton could never have written the Mass in B minor or the
Passion of St. Matthew even if he had possessed the musical genius of
Sebastian Bach. In this fact lies a further reason why genius is seldom
found at the same pitch in two successive generations; the combination
of mental characters always varies from father to son, and slight
displacements may give rise to very great differences in relation to
the manifestations of the specific talent. Under certain circumstances,
the weak development of a single trait of character, as, for instance,
power of action, or the excessive development of another, such as
indecision or desultoriness, may so nullify the existing favourable
combinations of mental characters, such as, let us say, musical sense,
inventive talent, depth of feeling, &c., that they bear no fruit
worth mentioning. And since as we have already seen, the different
mental qualities of the parents are to a certain extent separately
transmitted, that is, since they may appear in the children in the most
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account