A proof of this may be found in the results of experiments made upon
the little red-gold fire-butterfly (_Polyommatus phlæas_), to which
I have briefly referred in a former lecture. This little diurnal
butterfly of the family Lycænidæ has a wide distribution and occurs
in two climatic varieties. In the far north and also in the whole of
Germany the upper surface is red-gold with a narrow black outer margin,
but in the south of Europe the red-gold has been almost crowded out by
the black. I reared caterpillars in Germany from eggs of _P. phlæas_
found at Naples and exposed them directly after they had entered on
the pupa-stage to a relatively low temperature (10° C.). Butterflies
emerged which were not quite so black as those of Naples, but
considerably darker than the German form. Conversely, German pupæ were
exposed to greater warmth (38° C.), and these gave rise to butterflies
which were rather less fiery gold and considerably blacker than the
ordinary German form. If I had to repeat these experiments I should
use a much lower temperature in the case of the cold experiments,
because we now know from the experiments of Standfuss, E. Fischer, and
Bachmetjeff, that most of the pupæ of diurnal butterflies can stand a
temperature below zero for a considerable time; probably the results
would be even more marked then.
But even from the results of my former experiments we are justified
in concluding that the blackening of the upper surface of the wing is
really the direct result of the increased temperature during pupahood,
and that the pure red-gold results from the lowered temperature.
Similar experiments made by Merrifield with English _Phlæas_ pupæ agree
exactly with mine. But we may conclude further from these experiments
that both warmth and cold only give rise to slight variations in the
individual pupæ, and that the pure red-gold of the northern form
and the black of the southern are the result of a long process of
inheritance and accumulation, in which the germ-plasm has been caused
to vary in as far as the relevant determinants are concerned, so that
these yield the respective northern and southern forms even in less
extreme temperatures.
As it is to be assumed that these determinants are present not
only in the primordium of the wing in the pupa, but also in the
germ-cells, both must be affected by the varying temperature, and, in
accordance with the continuity of the germ-plasm, each variation of
these determinants, however slight, would be continued in the next
generation. It is thus intelligible that somatic variations like the
blackening of the wings through warmth appear to be directly inherited
and accumulate in the course of generations; in reality, however,
it is not the somatic change itself which is transmitted, but the
corresponding variation evoked by the same external influence in the
relevant determinants of the germ-plasm within the germ-cells, in other
words, in the determinants of the following generation.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account