In all these cases it is probably not always quite new paths which
are established in the brain, but use is made of particular tracks
in the innumerable nerve-paths already existing in the nerve-cells
(neurons) which are 'more thoroughly trodden' by practice, so that
the distribution of the nerve-current takes place more easily along
them than along others[13]. This much-used metaphor does not indicate
the actual structural changes which have taken place, but it serves
at least to indicate that we have to do with material changes in the
ultimate living elements of the nerve-substance (nerve-biophors)
whether these changes be in position or in quality. Now, if such
brain-structures and mechanisms acquired through exercise in the
individual life could be transmitted, new instincts would certainly
arise in this way, and many naturalists hold this view still.
[13] This, however, is by no means intended to cast doubt on the
possibility that quite new paths may arise during the individual life,
as is made probable by the recent investigations of Apáthy, Bethe, and
others.
If the inheritance of acquired characters had already been proved in
other ways, we could not refuse to admit that it might play a part in
the higher animals in the modification and new formation of instincts.
We should then have to admit that habits can be inherited, and that
instincts actually are or may be, as they have often been said to be,
inherited habits. But to make the converse conclusion, and to infer
from the result of the brain-exercise in the individual life and its
similarity to inborn instincts that the latter also depend on inherited
exercise, and that there must therefore be inheritance of acquired
characters, is hardly admissible.
It might be all very well if there were no other explanation! But as
instincts depend on material brain-mechanisms which are variable, like
every other part of the body, and as, furthermore, they are essential
to the existence of the species, and, down to the minutest detail, are
adapted to the circumstances of life, there is no obstacle in the way
of referring their origin and transformation to processes of selection.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account