But even though we may assume that there is a similar difference in the
mode of feeding among most ants, because the workers are considerably
smaller than the fertile females, it would be quite erroneous to
conclude that the difference between the two types rests solely on the
effect of differences in diet. The elimination of an individual organ
has never yet been determined by bad and scanty nourishment; it is the
whole animal with all its parts that degenerates and becomes small and
weakly. Often as caterpillars of different species have been placed
on starvation diet, whether for experimental purposes or to procure
very small butterflies, it has never yet happened that a single organ,
such as antenna, leg, or wing, has thereby been eliminated or caused
to degenerate. I have myself instituted many such experiments with the
maggots of the blue-bottle fly, by supplying them from their earliest
youth with just as little food as possible without actually starving
them to death, yet never have these larvæ given rise to flies in which
the wings were absent or rudimentary.
Nor did these starved flies ever exhibit degenerate ovaries; they
were always completely developed and equipped with the full number
of ovarian-tubes. It was to decide this particular point that
these experiments were instituted, for my opponents maintained
that degeneration of the ovaries was a direct result of inferior
nourishment. But that is not the case. Special investigations in regard
to ants, undertaken at my request by Miss Elizabeth Bickford, showed
that the anatomical results reached by earlier investigators, like
Adlerz and Lespès, in regard to the degeneration of the ovaries in
workers, were absolutely correct, and that the 'degeneration' consists
not merely in the fact that the ovarian-tubes and ovum-primordia remain
small, but also in a diminution of the _number_ of ovarian-tubes (Fig.
105); the workers have always fewer ovarian-tubes than the females of
the same species, and--what is of especial importance--the reduction
in the number of ovarian-tubes has been effected to a different extent
in different species of ants. In the red wood-ant (_Formica rufa_) the
workers still possess from twelve to sixteen ovarian-tubes; in the
meadow-ant (_Formica pratensis_) only eight, six, or four; in _Lasius
fuliginosus_ there are usually only two (one on either side); and in
the little turf-ant (_Tetramorium cæspitum_) there are none at all. We
have here, therefore, a phylogenetic process of degeneration, which
has reached different degrees in the different species, and has only
been completed in one (_Tetramorium_). The case stands as I previously
stated it: 'The elimination of a typical organ is not an ontogenetic
process, but a phylogenetic one,' it depends not upon 'the mere
influences of nutrition which affect the development of the individual,
but always on variations in the germ-plasm, which, to all appearance,
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account