The Expositor's Bible: The Pastoral EpistlesPlummer, Alfred
Religion
The Expositor's Bible: The Pastoral Epistles
Plummer, Alfred
Bible. Pastoral Epistles -- Criticism, interpretation, etc.
"Neither be partaker of other men's sins." It is usual to understand
this warning as referring to the responsibility of those who ordain. If,
through haste or carelessness you ordain an unfit person, you must
share the guilt of the sins which he afterwards commits as an elder. The
principle is a just one, but it may be doubted whether this is St.
Paul's meaning. The particular form of negative used seems to be against
it. He says "Nor _yet_ (μηδέ) be partaker of other men's sins," implying
that this is something different from hastiness in ordinary. He seems to
be returning to the warnings about partiality to elders who are living
in sin. The meaning, therefore, is--"Beware of a haste in ordaining
which may lead to the admission of unworthy men to the ministry. And if,
in spite of all your care, unworthy ministers come under your notice,
beware of an indifference or partiality towards them which will make you
a partaker in their sins." This interpretation fits on well to what
follows. "Keep _thyself_ pure"--with a strong emphasis on the pronoun.
"Strictness in enquiring into the antecedents of candidates for
ordination and in dealing with ministerial depravity will have a very
poor effect, unless your own life is free from reproach." And, if we
omit the parenthetical advice about taking wine, the thought is
continued thus: "As a rule it is not difficult to arrive at a wise
decision respecting the fitness of candidates, or the guilt of accused
presbyters. Men's characters both for evil and good are commonly
notorious. The vices of the wicked and the virtues of the good outrun
any formal judgment about them, and are quite manifest before an enquiry
is held. No doubt there are exceptions, and then the consequences of
men's lives must be looked to before a just opinion can be formed. But,
sooner or later (and generally sooner rather than later) men, and
especially ministers, will be known for what they are."
It remains to ascertain the meaning of the curious parenthesis "Be no
longer a drinker of water," and its connexion with the rest of the
passage.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account