I have explained in 'Science and Hypothesis' whence we derive the notion
of physical continuity and how that of mathematical continuity has
arisen from it. It happens that we are capable of distinguishing two
impressions one from the other, while each is indistinguishable from a
third. Thus we can readily distinguish a weight of 12 grams from a
weight of 10 grams, while a weight of 11 grams could be distinguished
from neither the one nor the other. Such a statement, translated into
symbols, may be written:
_A_ = _B_, _B_ = _C_, _A_ < _C_.
This would be the formula of the physical continuum, as crude experience
gives it to us, whence arises an intolerable contradiction that has
been obviated by the introduction of the mathematical continuum. This is
a scale of which the steps (commensurable or incommensurable numbers)
are infinite in number but are exterior to one another, instead of
encroaching on one another as do the elements of the physical continuum,
in conformity with the preceding formula.
The physical continuum is, so to speak, a nebula not resolved; the most
perfect instruments could not attain to its resolution. Doubtless if we
measured the weights with a good balance instead of judging them by the
hand, we could distinguish the weight of 11 grams from those of 10 and
12 grams, and our formula would become:
_A_ < _B_, _B_ < _C_, _A_ < _C_.
But we should always find between _A_ and _B_ and between _B_ and _C_
new elements _D_ and _E_, such that
_A_ = _D_, _D_ = _B_, _A_ < _B_;
_B_ = _E_, _E_ = _C_, _B_ < _C_,
and the difficulty would only have receded and the nebula would always
remain unresolved; the mind alone can resolve it and the mathematical
continuum it is which is the nebula resolved into stars.
Yet up to this point we have not introduced the notion of the number of
dimensions. What is meant when we say that a mathematical continuum or
that a physical continuum has two or three dimensions?
First we must introduce the notion of cut, studying first physical
continua. We have seen what characterizes the physical continuum. Each
of the elements of this continuum consists of a manifold of impressions;
and it may happen either that an element can not be discriminated from
another element of the same continuum, if this new element corresponds
to a manifold of impressions not sufficiently different, or, on the
contrary, that the discrimination is possible; finally it may happen
that two elements indistinguishable from a third may, nevertheless, be
distinguished one from the other.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account