But first, even though this direct intuition made known to us the real
nature of force in itself, it would be insufficient as a foundation for
mechanics; it would besides be wholly useless. What is of importance is
not to know what force is, but to know how to measure it.
Whatever does not teach us to measure it is as useless to mechanics as
is, for instance, the subjective notion of warmth and cold to the
physicist who is studying heat. This subjective notion can not be
translated into numbers, therefore it is of no use; a scientist whose
skin was an absolutely bad conductor of heat and who, consequently,
would never have felt either sensations of cold or sensations of warmth,
could read a thermometer just as well as any one else, and that would
suffice him for constructing the whole theory of heat.
Now this immediate notion of effort is of no use to us for measuring
force; it is clear, for instance, that I should feel more fatigue in
lifting a weight of fifty kilos than a man accustomed to carry burdens.
But more than that: this notion of effort does not teach us the real
nature of force; it reduces itself finally to a remembrance of muscular
sensations, and it will hardly be maintained that the sun feels a
muscular sensation when it draws the earth.
All that can there be sought is a symbol, less precise and less
convenient than the arrows the geometers use, but just as remote from
the reality.
Anthropomorphism has played a considerable historic rôle in the genesis
of mechanics; perhaps it will still at times furnish a symbol which will
appear convenient to some minds; but it can not serve as foundation for
anything of a truly scientific or philosophic character.
'THE SCHOOL OF THE THREAD.'--M. Andrade, in his _Leçons de mécanique
physique_, has rejuvenated anthropomorphic mechanics. To the school of
mechanics to which Kirchhoff belongs, he opposes that which he bizarrely
calls the school of the thread.
This school tries to reduce everything to "the consideration of certain
material systems of negligible mass, envisaged in the state of tension
and capable of transmitting considerable efforts to distant bodies,
systems of which the ideal type is the _thread_."
A thread which transmits any force is slightly elongated under the
action of this force; the direction of the thread tells us the direction
of the force, whose magnitude is measured by the elongation of the
thread.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account