New England -- History -- Colonial period, ca. 1600-1775
Criticism of the leaders' actions was severe and constant, even from
their best friends in England. The real father of the colony, the
Reverend John White, wrote to Winthrop in alarm, saying that he desired
him “to have an eye to one thinge, that you fall not into that evill
abroad, which you labored to avoyd at home, to binde all men to the same
tenets and practise.” Stansby, in a letter to the Reverend Mr. Wilson,
complained that, on account of their strictness, over one half of the
people were not admitted to church membership, and that this would do
them much harm. Stephen Winthrop, temporarily in London, sent home word
to his brother John, that “here is great complaint against us for our
severity against Anabaptists. It doth discourage any people from coming
to us for fear they should be banished if they dissent from us in
opinion.” Sir George Downing, a cousin of the younger Winthrop, in a
letter retailing English opinion of the colony, speaks of that “law of
banishing for conscience, which makes us stinke everywhere.”[421]
Footnote 421:
_Mass. Hist. Soc. Coll._, Series V, vol. I, p. 252; Series IV, vol.
VII, p. 11; Series V, vol. VIII, p. 200; Series IV, vol. VI, p. 537.
Nor must the standpoint of the English citizen be neglected. England's
American possessions, in spite of monopolies and charters, were coming
more and more to be looked upon as the heritage of the English people,
as the land of opportunity for those who fell by the wayside in life's
race at home, as well as for religious exiles. Yet here was one of the
best parts of the whole continent being monopolized by a band of people
who rejected, oppressed, and banished others, or at the least deprived
them of all political rights, not because they were undesirable
citizens, not because they were immoral, but because they refused to
conform to the peculiar church polity and doctrine, neither Church of
England nor English Puritan, which the first settlers had evolved in the
American wilderness.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account