Free thought; Modernism (Christian theology) -- Catholic Church; Religion and science; Teaching, Freedom of
He who knows even the fundamental ideas of _Kant’s_ “Kritik der
reinen Vernunft” will see that not only the Catholic Church, but
every Christian denomination, might forfeit its existence if it
showed itself indifferent towards it. Heresies are especially
dangerous to the uneducated when they bear the names of authors of
scientific repute. But the Church willingly grants the permission
to read them when there is reason for it. Moreover, it was not
Rome alone that took steps against _Kant_. This was done by the
Prussian king _Frederick II._ also. One may recall his cabinet
order, under minister _Woellner_, against Kant’s “Religion
innerhalb der Grenzen der blossen Vernunft.” Similarly the works
of _Spinoza_ were proceeded against, whereas his indictment by
Rome now calls forth protest because he has since been assigned a
prominent place among philosophers. _Freudenthal_ registers a list
of 500 sharp prohibitions issued against _Spinoza’s_ works during
the years 1556-1580: they were condemned by the states of Holland,
by the court, by synods and magistrates. Those judgments were
passed during a period when the competent authorities had views
different from those of to-day; when the state deemed it its duty
to oppose the undermining of Christianity. The state’s judgment
has changed in many ways, Rome’s judgment has remained the same.
But the works of _Kant_ and _Spinoza_ likewise have remained the
same, and so is Christianity, against which they occupy an
irreconcilable position, still the same.
“In the moral world nothing can support that cannot also resist” is a
truthful saying of _Treitschke_: it is also the principle of the Catholic
Church. Without ever surrendering to the unchristian tendency of a time,
she opposes error with unsubdued courage. If this be intolerance, it is
not intolerance towards erring men but towards their errors, it is the
intolerance that the gardener shows in uprooting harmful weeds, it is the
intolerance of the physician towards disease. Obedience to the Index makes
high moral demands upon the Catholic. But it has been characteristic of
the Christian religion and of its faithful children never to shrink before
any moral action where it appeared demanded. And if the preservation of
moral purity exacts conscientious discipline, this is also true of the
preservation of the pure faith, especially at a time when a neo-paganism
in league with an uncontrolled mania for reading is threatening in many
forms.
Galileo, and Other Topics.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account