Free thought; Modernism (Christian theology) -- Catholic Church; Religion and science; Teaching, Freedom of
Of course, to him who takes the position of _Kant’s_ _dualism of belief
and rational judgment_, freedom from every authority in matters of faith,
and in this sense tolerance, will appear to be self-evident. Whatever has
nothing to do with knowledge, but is merely the personal result of an
inner, subjective experience, cannot be offered by external authority as
matter for instruction. The sole standard for this belief is the
autonomous subject and its own needs. In this sense _Harnack_ tells us:
“The kernel of one’s being is to be grasped in its own depths and the soul
is merely to recognize its own needs and the road traced out for their
gratification. This can only be done with the fullest freedom. Any
restraint here is tantamount to the destruction of the problem; any
submission to the teaching of others ... is treason to one’s own religion”
(Religioeser Glaube und freie Forschung. Neue Freie Presse, 7. Juni,
1908). To have one’s religion determined by any authority, even a divine
one, would be treason to the sovereignty of man!
Viewed from this standpoint, the _reconciliation between faith and
science_ is no longer a problem. And they congratulate themselves on the
solution of this vexing question. Now, they say, deliverance from an
oppressive misery has been found, now the peace sought for so long is
restored. A fair division has been made: two worlds, the world of the
senses, and the world above sense experience. One belongs to science,
where it now rules supreme; the other belongs to faith, where it can move
freely, undisturbed by, and even unapproachable to science. Just as the
stars in the sky are inaccessible to the custodian of civil order,—he can
neither support them nor hinder them, nor pull them down,—just so the
realm of faith is inaccessible to science: peace reigns everywhere.
Cheered on by this treaty of peace, _Paulsen_ writes: “Thus
critical philosophy has solved the old problem of the relation of
knowledge to faith. _Kant_ is convinced that by properly setting
the limits he has succeeded in laying the foundation for real and
enduring peace between them. In fact, upon this in the first place
will rest the importance and vitality of his philosophy. It gives
to knowledge, on the one hand, what belongs to it for unlimited
research, the whole world of phenomena; on the other hand it gives
to faith its eternal right, the interpretation of life and the
world from the view-point of values. There can be no doubt that
herein lies the cause of the great impression made by _Kant_ upon
his time; he appeared as the liberator from unbearable suspense”
(Immanuel Kant, 1898, 6).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account