The Frontiers of Language and Nationality in EuropeDominian, Leon
History
The Frontiers of Language and Nationality in Europe
Dominian, Leon
Europe -- Languages; Nationalism
The preëminence of the linguistic factor set forth in these pages
may be illustrated concisely by the accepted recognition of the
“langue d’oïl” as the national language of France by all Frenchmen
of the present day, although this would have been impossible five
centuries ago. Adoption of the linguistic criterion in boundary
delimitation becomes, therefore, a mere matter of expediency. Its
worth is not due to any assumed abstract value of language. It
is merely a practical manner of settling divergences regarding
national ownership of border territories. It is of value because
the guiding consideration in boundary delimitation or revision is
to eliminate future sources of conflict.
The European war is no exception to the fact that almost every
conflict of magnitude has been due, in part, to ill-adjusted
frontier lines. Slight regard for national aspirations seems
to have prevailed in the delimitations determined upon by the
signatory powers of every important treaty. The seed of ulterior
fighting was thus sown, for one of the main features of modern
history is the growth of national feeling as a dominating force in
human affairs.
With Europe rid of Napoleon, the treaty of Vienna was framed by
his allied foes in 1815 for the purpose of recasting the political
map. No heed was paid, however, to the legitimate desire of
smaller European nations to rule themselves. An instance of some
of the gross blunders committed then was the merging of Belgium
and Holland into one nationality in spite of the protests of their
representatives. Feelings of the bitterest nature between Belgians
and Dutch engendered by this act ultimately forced a war between
the two countries in 1830. It was only after their separation
that the enmity of the two peoples gave way to cordial relations.
Subsequent history has shown that these two nations have often been
of greater help to each other while retaining separate political
entity than under forced union. In Italy also the progress made
towards union by Italian-speaking peoples was checked by this
treaty and the country split once more into a number of small
independent states. The assignation of Lombardy and Venetia to
Austria led eventually to the war of 1859.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account