The Frontiers of Language and Nationality in EuropeDominian, Leon
History
The Frontiers of Language and Nationality in Europe
Dominian, Leon
Europe -- Languages; Nationalism
The practical value of linguistic frontiers as national boundaries
is due to their geographical growth. They are natural because
they are the result of human intercourse based largely on
economic needs. Having developed naturally, they correspond to
national aspirations. Such being the case, the task of frontier
delimitation can be made to assume a scientific form. Only in
the case of uninhabited or sparsely populated regions will an
artificial boundary--say, of the straight line type--prove
adequate. But in tenanted portions of the earth’s surface where
human wills and desires come into play the problem cannot be
dismissed so lightly. The ordinary laws of science must then be
applied. This, after all, merely implies drawing on the stock of
common sense accumulated by the human race in the course of its
development. The clear duty of statesmen engaged in a revision of
boundaries is to put the varied interests at stake into harmony
with the facts of nature as they are revealed by geography. This is
possible because the science deals with the surface of the earth
considered as the field of man’s activity. Its data can be drawn
upon just as successfully as the engineer draws upon the energy of
a waterfall or a ton of coal. Soundness and permanency of the labor
of delimitation can thus be insured.
The preceding remarks should not be considered as implying that
a mountain, or a river, or even the sea are to be arbitrarily
regarded as frontiers. Lines of water-parting deserve particular
mention as having provided satisfactory national borders in
history. But in boundaries each case should be treated upon its own
merits. There was a time when, in Cowper’s words:
Mountains interposed
Make enemies of nations who had else
Like kindred drops been mingled into one.
And yet the passes of the Alps refute the poet’s statement. Their
uniting function eventually overcame their estranging power. The
easterly spread of French language over the Vosges concurs in the
same trend of testimony. The imposing mass of the Urals is no more
of a parting than are the Appalachians. To be pertinent, it will
be necessary, in each instance, to consider the complex operations
of natural laws and the process of fusing and building up of
nationality brought about by their agency.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account