An English physician opposes compulsory vaccination on the ground that
it prevents further discovery, and compels medical science to halt at
just that point, because it forbids experiment upon methods of
prevention that may prove to be better. He says: "It stereotypes a
particular stage of scientific knowledge, and bars further progress. If
I remind you of the great improvement thought to have been made by the
introduction of inoculation by Lady Mary Wortley Montagu at the end of
the last century, and ask you to suppose that Parliament might then have
passed an act to compel every one to be inoculated, you will, I think,
see what is meant. This method was tried for some years with great
_éclat_, but afterward it was found to spread the smallpox so much that
an act of Parliament was passed to forbid its use. Vaccination,
introduced by Dr. Jenner, has followed, and this was another step in
advance. I was the first child in my father's family vaccinated
seventy-one years ago, several elder brothers and sisters having been
inoculated. Both methods answered in our cases. But for many years I
have been satisfied that other diseases besides the modified small-pox
(called cow-pox) are now introduced by the old vaccine, and have
steadily refused to use it, seeking rather, at increased trouble and
expense, new vaccine. And the question which comes forcibly to the front
is this: May not some other preservative be discovered which shall be a
further improvement? This question cannot be answered so long as
vaccination is compelled by law. There are no persons upon whom
experiments can be tried." So far as it goes, this is valid ground for
criticising vaccination laws. But the proof that small-pox is more
disastrous to the human race than the evils that vaccination brings with
it is so strong that there is little likelihood society will subject
itself to the attacks of the greater enemy in order to avoid the lesser.
The evils of the old system of using vaccine taken from human beings for
new inoculations are now no longer inevitable. Fresh vaccine direct from
the calf, and called "Bovine," can be had everywhere. A large
establishment for obtaining it is situated near New York.
CURRENT LITERATURE.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account