The geographical lore of the time of the Crusades : $b A study in the history of medieval science and tradition in Western EuropeWright, John Kirtland
History
The geographical lore of the time of the Crusades : $b A study in the history of medieval science and tradition in Western Europe
Wright, John Kirtland
Geography -- History; Geography, Medieval
This sort of reasoning, however, was exceptional. In the mid-twelfth
century the appearance of Peter Lombard’s _Sententiae_ tended to divert
the theologian’s mind from Platonic and rationalistic studies and to
restore Church Fathers and Scripture to paramount authority.[581] We
look in vain for traces of the liberal attitude of the Chartres scholars
in the orthodox works of such prolific writers but perhaps less clear
thinkers as Peter Comestor, Giraldus Cambrensis, Gervase of Tilbury or
even Alexander Neckam. Giraldus’ _Symbolum electorum_[582] contains a
cosmography in verse which explains the Scriptural view of the Works of
the Six Days, and though we feel in this poem the influence of the
Peripatetic physics—which by this time were becoming universally
known—no attempt was made to expound the work of the Creation according
to physical laws. In the _Topographia Hiberniae_[583] Giraldus
illustrates his own attitude and the dominant attitude of his age by the
moral he draws from the story of eagles which occasionally fly so high
that they scorch their wings in the sun. This he compared to the
hopeless vanity of the man who tries to solve by reason or by knowledge
God’s riddles of the Creation and of the universe. Neckam also despairs
of explaining the mysteries of nature and asks, “Who may comprehend the
causes of things?” He describes thunder and lightning briefly but adds,
“The herald of the thunder fills the mind with terror and shows how
great is the creator thereof.”[584] Even Michael Scot, who enjoyed the
patronage of the enlightened, scientifically minded Emperor Frederick
II, attributed the fact that the waters of the spherical earth are held
in place to “a secret virtue ... beyond human ken and merit”
(Haskins).[585] Gervase of Tilbury reproduces uncritically in his _Otia
imperialia_[586] the ideas compiled by Peter Comestor regarding the
Creation. These were strictly correct opinions on which no suspicion of
heterodoxy could be thrown. Comestor went out of his way to express
opposition and antagonism to Platonic teachings.
EFFECTS OF INFLUX OF ARABIC SCIENCE
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account