The geographical lore of the time of the Crusades : $b A study in the history of medieval science and tradition in Western EuropeWright, John Kirtland
History
The geographical lore of the time of the Crusades : $b A study in the history of medieval science and tradition in Western Europe
Wright, John Kirtland
Geography -- History; Geography, Medieval
Though these passages reveal to us belief during the Crusading age in
the presence of heat and fire in the inside of the earth, the teachings
of Plato and many of the Church Fathers that the sources of volcanic
fires spring from immense subterranean reservoirs of fire do not appear
to have been given much credence. Though the earth’s crust and even its
innermost heart might be interpenetrated with cavities into which air,
water, and fire enter, confidence in the essential solidity and
massiveness of the earth prevailed, and theories which would admit of
the presence of bodies of water or of fire of any great extent within
the heaviest and most solid of the elements were not regarded as worthy
of serious consideration. Hell, however, was almost universally placed
at the very center of the earth by medieval theologians and geographers
alike.[1035]
EARTHQUAKES
The majority of medieval writers believed that earthquakes are caused by
the same physical forces as those which produce volcanic eruptions, the
violent stirring of winds,[1036] vapors, or exhalations within the
earth’s crust.[1037] In the _Quaestiones naturales_ of Adelard of Bath,
which takes the form of a dialogue between uncle and nephew, the nephew
finds it difficult to reconcile the stability and immobility of the
earth, which his uncle had just demonstrated, with the well-known fact
that the earth sometimes quakes and trembles. To this Adelard replies
that, while it is true that the earth may occasionally move in
particular localities, it does not move as a whole[1038] and that
earthquakes are caused by the air contained within the earth and have
nothing whatever to do with the intrinsically stable qualities of the
earth as a globe. He then proceeds to give the Aristotelian explanation
of the causes of earthquakes.[1039] The _De imagine mundi_, followed by
the _Image du monde_ and by Bartholomew Anglicus,[1040] also assigns the
same causes; and William of Conches explains[1041] that earthquakes are
the result of waters descending into underground hollows where they
encounter vapors, condensed into cloudlike form by the coldness of the
earth’s interior; these vapors, in turn, produce telluric movements by
forcing their way to the surface. Neckam repeats much the same
explanation but adds the usual allegorical lesson:[1042] the land
symbolizes the Church, which, although on the whole serene and firm, may
well be shaken now and then by purely local troubles and disturbances.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account