The Golden Bough: A Study in Magic and Religion (Third Edition, Vol. 04 of 12)Frazer, James George
Religion
The Golden Bough: A Study in Magic and Religion (Third Edition, Vol. 04 of 12)
Frazer, James George
Magic; Mythology; Religion; Superstition
NOTE A. CHINESE INDIFFERENCE TO DEATH.
(M214) Lord Avebury kindly allows me to print the letter of Mr. M. W.
Lampson, referred to above (p. 146, note 1). It runs as follows:—
FOREIGN OFFICE, _August 7, 1903_.
DEAR LORD AVEBURY—As the result of enquiries I hear from a Mr.
Eames, a lawyer who practised for some years at Shanghai and has
considerable knowledge of Chinese matters, that for a small sum a
substitute can be found for execution. This is recognised by the
Chinese authorities, with certain exceptions, as for instance
parricide. It is even asserted that the local Taotai gains
pecuniarily by this arrangement, as he is as a rule not above
obtaining a substitute for the condemned man for a less sum than
was paid him by the latter.
It is, I believe, part of the doctrine of Confucius that it is one
of the highest virtues to increase the family prosperity at the
expense of personal suffering. According to Eames, the Chinamen
[_sic_] looks upon execution in another man’s stead in this light,
and consequently there is quite a competition for such a
“substitution.”
Should you wish to get more definite information, the address is:
W. Eames, Esq., c/o Norman Craig, Inner Temple, E.C.
The only man in this department who has actually been out to China
is at present away. But on his return I will ask him about it.—
Yours sincerely,
MILES W. LAMPSON.
(M215) On this subject Lord Avebury had stated: “It is said that in China,
if a rich man is condemned to death, he can sometimes purchase a willing
substitute at a very small expense.”(726) In regard to his authority for
this statement Lord Avebury wrote to me (August 10, 1903): “I believe my
previous information came from Sir T. Wade, but I have been unable to lay
my hand on his letter, and do not therefore like to state it as a fact.”
Sir Thomas Wade was English Ambassador at Peking, and afterwards Professor
of Chinese at Cambridge.
(M216) On the same subject Mr. Valentine Chirol, editor of the foreign
department of _The Times_, wrote to me as follows:—
QUEEN ANNE’S MANSIONS, WESTMINSTER, S.W.,
_August 21st, 1905_.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account