The Goslings: A Study of the American SchoolsSinclair, Upton
History
The Goslings: A Study of the American Schools
Sinclair, Upton
Education -- United States
Miss Flora Menzel of Milwaukee came in 1923, with instructions to
recommend certain policies on behalf of her group. She was put on the
“credentials committee,” and wandered about the corridors of the Oakland
Hotel trying to find out where this committee met. The meeting was set
for a certain hour; she succeeded in finding the place, fifteen minutes
late, and there was no one in the room. Subsequently she ascertained
that the “credentials committee” had already met, named a sub-committee
of the gang, and adjourned in fifteen minutes! And that is only one of
many devices whereby classroom teachers known to be loyal to their own
groups are shunted to one side. In 1921, at Des Moines, they appointed a
committee on the revision of elementary education, and they made it up
of college presidents and professors, state superintendents, the United
States Commissioner of Education—and one elementary teacher. They were
going to determine the policy of the N. E. A. toward the most important
of all subjects connected with the schools, and they put on this
committee just one person who was having actual experience with
children!
For more than twenty years Margaret Haley has been fighting in the
interest of the teachers for action on salaries, tenure and pensions. It
took ten years to get them to adopt resolutions on the question, and ten
years more to get them to do anything. I have told about the Atlantic
City mid-winter convention of 1918, at which the Department of
Superintendence planned the Salt Lake City swindle, and how Miss Frances
Harden was there, having paid her own substitute. She was representing
Margaret Haley, who had been put on the committee for salaries, tenure
and pensions. The chairman of the committee was President Joseph Swain
of Swarthmore College, past president of the N. E. A. President Swain
got up and made a momentous announcement: two young men from the
Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching had been giving him
invaluable assistance on this pension question. The two young men were
present, and thus introduced they practically ran the committee
throughout the sessions. They had a “model teachers’ pension bill,” and
they asked the endorsement of the Department of Superintendence, after
which they proposed to take the bill to each of the states, and get the
endorsement of the state educational machines, and then force it through
the legislature.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account