The Goslings: A Study of the American SchoolsSinclair, Upton
History
The Goslings: A Study of the American Schools
Sinclair, Upton
Education -- United States
All over this country the hunt for the unorthodox text-book is going on,
and the principle upon which the revisers are working is set forth by
Edward Mandel, district superintendent of schools in New York, who
ordered every school principal in the city to direct his teachers of
history to examine the history books and transmit reports. Said Mr.
Mandel: “The question to be considered is not one of whether statements
made in the text-books are truthful and based on fact, but whether
propriety would be observed if they were included in them.” You will not
be surprised to hear that this educational gang-leader went up to
Albany, and was active in pushing through a series of bills known to the
teachers as the “spoils bills,” their purpose being to undermine the
merit system and give the gang entire control over promotions; and when
he got through with this job, he was promoted to be associate
superintendent at a considerably higher salary.
The final goal of these patriots has been reached in Arkansas, where the
state legislature has just passed a bill providing exactly how American
history shall be taught; the teachers are to avoid “a mere recital of
names and events,” and devote themselves to “instilling an understanding
and a love of country,” etc. In other words, there is to be no more
history, only propaganda; and any teacher who slips up on it is to be
fined from one hundred to five hundred dollars, or to serve in jail from
thirty days to six months, or both. As we used to say when we were
youngsters, and had got somebody down with our thumb in his eye: “Now
will you be good?”
The leader in the crusade against what he calls “treason texts” is Mr.
Charles Grant Miller, organizing director of the “Patriot League.” Mr.
Miller tells me how “for years in my newspaper work I have encountered
evils arising from the rivalries of text-book publishers and their
unscrupulous methods of manipulating school officials and intimidating
teachers.” He then goes on to tell how the Patriot League has set to
work to give the text-book companies a dose of their own medicine. The
haughty American Book Company has been brought to its knees; they
submitted to Mr. Miller the proofs of a new school history, which had
won the endorsement of the Sons of the American Revolution. But it
didn’t suit Mr. Miller; he specified over three hundred unsatisfactory
passages, and the American Book Company agreed to accept ninety-five per
cent of these corrections. It has just sent Mr. Miller proofs of another
school history, which he finds to be ninety-nine per cent all right from
his viewpoint. Then they asked him to read in manuscript a new high
school history; says Mr. Miller:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account