The Goslings: A Study of the American SchoolsSinclair, Upton
History
The Goslings: A Study of the American Schools
Sinclair, Upton
Education -- United States
This same young man told me of his experiences when he was selected to
deliver the valedictory of his class. He asked to have a liberal teacher
as his guide, but was compelled to have a reactionary teacher. She
assigned to him a commonplace theme, and he rejected it, and wrote on
the subject of “Labor’s Right to a Share in Industry.” When he brought
in his address, the teacher refused to let him deliver it; it was “too
Bolsheviki,” she said, and told him that when he went into a garden he
must see the beautiful red roses, and not the thorns. She practically
rewrote the address for the student, and he took it off and wrote it
again. The controversy continued up to a day or two before commencement,
when the boy finally had to deliver an address which did not represent
his own convictions.
I have mentioned favoritism among the principals and teachers; needless
to say, also, that children who come from poor homes, and especially the
children of foreigners, are slighted. A boy came to see me, Clarence
Alpert by name, a sensitive lad, conscientious and idealistic; with
tears in his eyes he told me how he had been turned out of Lincoln High
School by the principal, Miss Andrus. I was familiar with the name of
this lady. In an address to the school assembly she had referred to
“that notorious disloyalist and traitor, Upton Sinclair.” I wrote a
letter to the lady in which I mentioned my support of the war—you may
find it in “The Brass Check,” pages 205-7. I served notice upon her that
she would make a retraction of her statements or face a libel suit, and
she preferred the former alternative.
The boy whom she had now expelled had refused to salute the flag. He was
a Socialist, and believed that the flag stood for capitalism. Miss
Andrus sent for him, and stormed at him; he was a Russian Jew, and she
knew his kind from her experience at Hull House. They were dirty, rotten
scoundrels; they were people with no ideals and no country; they were
cheap material, who could not be made into good citizens and were not
entitled to an education. Miss Andrus tried her best to get young Alpert
to name some of the teachers who had encouraged him in his ideas; the
boy was threatened with immediate dismissal if he refused to name them,
but in spite of the fact that he had “no ideals,” he stood firm! Finally
he was given three days in which to make up his mind and salute the
flag.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account