The Goslings: A Study of the American SchoolsSinclair, Upton
History
The Goslings: A Study of the American Schools
Sinclair, Upton
Education -- United States
A form of “honest graft” which has been widely developed under this
Tammany regime is the writing of text-books by school officials. Many of
the text-books in use in the public schools of New York bear the names
of people in the system; in many cases they were written by teachers,
but officials have put their names upon them, and get the greater part
of the profits. The principals recommend these books for use, and the
board of superintendents adopts them. Former Superintendent Maxwell had
a large income from books published by the American Book Company which
he himself had not written; and a number of the district superintendents
get their share. The New York “Globe,” discussing the case of Maxwell,
showed how in his position he had the power to increase the sales of his
own books; and this same power is possessed by all the gang. I was told
of one head of a department with a book to sell, who got himself
transferred three times to different parts of the city—starting in the
High School of Commerce in Manhattan, from there to the Commercial High
School of Brooklyn, and then to Long Island—and in each place he took
with him his commercial arithmetic. The teachers did not want it, but in
every school the other texts were thrown out and the new one introduced.
All over New York—and all over America, as we shall find—there are
school basements and cupboards filled with discarded text-books, or new
text-books which are so bad that the teachers will not use them.
Needless to say, many of the Tammany superintendents and principals are
ignorant men, utterly unfitted for scholastic duties. I look back on my
own days in the College of the City of New York, and recall the comical
old boys whom the Tammany machine appointed to teach me literature and
philosophy and Latin, and other high-brow subjects. Therefore, I was not
surprised to be told of a superintendent who talks about “algebray,” and
who says: “As I was a-saying,” etc. The French teachers find amusement
in the efforts of superintendents to pretend that they know French. I
talked with a charming lady of Spanish birth, who attempted to get by
one of these examiners, but he reported her French as “very bad”; she
“ran all her words together.” Anyone who has listened to a Frenchman
talk will appreciate the humor of this comment; one might say that the
first qualification for speaking good French is to run your words
together to the utmost possible extent. This lady went to see Professor
Cohn, head of the department of French of Columbia University, and one
of our leading French scholars. He reported that she spoke French “like
a native,” and took occasion to add that he knew the examiner in
question, and knew him to be ignorant of French.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account