The Gospel of the HereafterSmyth, J. Paterson (John Paterson)
Religion
The Gospel of the Hereafter
Smyth, J. Paterson (John Paterson)
Eschatology
Something similar is true about the texts whose chief word is "Hell."
The word "hell" occurs eighteen times in the Authorized Version. Once
it is a translation of a Greek word Tartarus (2 Peter ii. 4) cast down
to Hell to be reserved "_unto the Day of Judgment_." That certainly
was not everlasting. Five times it is a translation of the word Hades
whose meaning we already know, and which certainly did not mean
everlasting. The other twelve times it is a translation of the word
Gehenna used by our Lord, and no scholar with the least regard for his
reputation would dream of stating that our Lord certainly meant it to
convey the idea of endlessness. It was the name of a horrible valley
outside Jerusalem where things were cast out to be burnt, to keep the
city pure. The Jewish prophets took the word as a metaphor to express
the fate of wicked men. From it they drew their images used by our
Lord of "the worm that dieth not and the fire that is not quenched"
(Mark x. 46). To be in danger of Gehenna was to be in danger of a
hereafter doom suggested by this dread place.
Our Lord simply took up the vague Jewish word and did not define it.
What exactly had He in His mind when He used this word? This is a
question of terrible importance. He certainly meant something very
stern and awful. He seems to indicate also something final and
irrevocable. But there is absolutely no reason to believe that He
meant to convey the idea in our minds of a vast prison, in which the
souls of the lost are pierced through with agony for ever and ever.
You ask, How can I know what He meant? How could I know what
Shakespeare meant by a certain word? I should read up all the books
and letters of Shakespeare's times in which the word occurs, and
whatever it commonly meant to the people of Shakespeare's time I should
accept as being what Shakespeare meant. That looks sensible, does it
not? Well, a very interesting investigation has been made by various
scholars. They have examined all the existing Jewish writings where
the word Gehenna was used from 300 B. C. to 300 A. D. Then they have
examined the Jewish Talmuds which run on to the fourth and fifth
century. A modern English scholar, Dr. Dewes, says (_Plea for a New
Translation_, p. 23): "Every passage has been carefully examined which
is quoted in the works of Lightfoot, Schoetgen, Buxtorf, Castell,
Schindler, Glass, Bartoloccius, Ugalino and Nork, and the result of the
whole examination is this: _there are only two passages which even a
superficial reader could consider to be corroborative of the assertion
that the Jews understood Gehenna to be a place of everlasting torment_."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account