The gradual acceptance of the Copernican theory of the universeStimson, Dorothy
History
The gradual acceptance of the Copernican theory of the universe
Stimson, Dorothy
Astronomy -- History; Copernicus, Nicolaus, 1473-1543; Solar system
Reasons for the belief that the earth is moved:
1. The sun, the most excellent, the greatest and the midmost star,
rightly stands still like a king while all the other stars with the
earth swing round it.
2. That you believe that the heavens revolve is due to ocular
deception similar to that of a man on a ship leaving shore.
3. That Joshua bade the sun stand still Moses wrote for the people in
accordance with the popular misconception.
4. As the planets are each a special created thing in the heavens, so
the earth is a similar creation and similarly revolves.
5. The sun fitly rests at the center as the heart does in the middle
of the human body.
6. Since the earth has in itself its especial _centrum_, a stone or an
arrow falls freely out of the air again to its own _centrum_ as do all
earthly things.
7. The earth can move five miles in a second more readily than the sun
can go forty miles in the same time.
And similarly on both sides.[325]
[Footnote 322: Schotto: _Organum Mathematicum_ (1667).]
[Footnote 323: Voight: _Der Kunstgünstigen Einfalt Mathematischer
Raritäten Erstes Hundert_. (Hamburg, 1667).]
[Footnote 324: Voight: _op. cit._: 28.]
[Footnote 325: Ibid: 30-31.]
Another writer preferring the Tychonic scheme was Longomontanus, whose
_Astronomica Danica_ (Amsterdam, 1640) upheld this theory because it
"obviates the absurdities of the Copernican hypothesis and most aptly
corresponds to celestial appearances," and also because it is "midway
between that and the Ptolemaic one."[326] Even though he speaks of the
"apparent motion of the sun," he attributed diurnal motion to the
heavens, and believed the earth was at the center of the universe
because (1), from the account of the Creation, the heaven and the
earth were first created, and what could be more likely than that the
heavens should fill the space between the center (the earth) and the
circumference? (2) and because of the incredibly enormous interval
between the sphere of the fixed stars and the earth necessitated by
Copernican doctrine.[327]
[Footnote 326: Longomontanus: _Op. cit._: 162.]
[Footnote 327: Longomontanus: _Op. cit._: 158.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account