The Grateful Dead: The History of a Folk StoryGerould, Gordon Hall
General
The Grateful Dead: The History of a Folk Story
Gerould, Gordon Hall
Dead -- Folklore; Folk literature -- Themes, motives; Grateful dead (Tale)
In the following versions the hero is saved on the wedding night, or
the bride is purified by some means: Tobit, Armenian, Gypsy, Siberian,
Russian I., Russian II., Russian III., Russian IV., Russian V., Russian
VI., Servian II., Servian III., Servian IV., Bulgarian, Esthonian II.,
Irish I., Irish II., Danish III., Norwegian II., and Harz I. Not all
the stories which I have placed in the group, it will be observed,
have this feature; but, out of all the variants of The Grateful Dead
enumerated in the bibliographical list, not one has it except members
of the group. Now this purification of the bride, by means of which
the hero is saved, is precisely the element of The Poison Maiden which
is most essential. There can be no doubt, therefore, that this theme
actually united with a more primitive form of The Grateful Dead to
form the compound discussed in this chapter. The combination must
have been made very early and in Asia, as Tobit and Armenian bear
witness. It will be noted that all the variants, save Finnish, which
have the simple compound, retain the rescue of the bridegroom, while
only half of those where a subsidiary motive has been introduced have
the like. Apparently the intrusion of new matter of a very romantic
sort tended to obscure the original climax of the combined type.
Another feature of much importance in this connection is the division
of the woman, or whatever is substituted for it. In a large majority
of the variants studied, which have the trait at all, the purpose
of the division proposed or accomplished is to test the fidelity of
the hero. Hippe believed [102] that this was a modification of the
original trait, an opinion which would be justified if the compound
type The Grateful Dead + The Poison Maiden only were considered. The
versions which have the purification are the following: Armenian,
Gypsy, Siberian, Russian II., Russian IV., Russian V., Russian VI.,
Servian II., Servian III., Servian IV., Bulgarian, Esthonian II.,
Finnish, Irish I., Irish II., and Old Wives' Tale. In these the
purpose of the division, or beating, whether actually performed or
not, is the disposal of serpents or other venomous creatures by which
the woman is possessed. [103] It will be noted, however, that all
of these variants are of the type treated in the present chapter. If
the division for the sake of purification were then regarded as more
primitive and older than the division for the sake of sharing the
gains or of testing the hero, it would naturally follow that all
the combined types must proceed from The Grateful Dead + The Poison
Maiden. Hippe followed the logical course from his premises in so
regarding the relationship of the groups. [104] However, it seems
clear to me--and it will be increasingly evident as we study the
other groups--that the division for purification belongs solely to
the compound treated in this chapter. It would follow logically from
combining The Poison Maiden, where a friend saves the hero from the
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account